I started out just looking around to see what the real deal was with some of these religions, since the wt had given us extreamly biased info about them. I first looked at the big fish and their cut on spirituality/spiritual practices like Christ, Mohammed, Budda, Taoism, Wicca, Chicken Soup for the Soul, etc (well ok maybe not the last one, but it helped me to see what I thought was 'spiritual' or not).
I decided on a top 3 that seemed to fit my conclusion about the world that I live in: Christ, Taoism and Wicca. I took some time to try out some of the basics of each to get a general feel and found uplifting things in each. However, love, peace and natural harmony seemed to be at the heart of all 3 and I find that meshes with my own worldview. The one that seemed to be 'naturally me' was Christ's with a little Tao here and there. Nothing against Wicca, it just didn't feel as natural to me, although I do like many of the principles of love and harmony within Wicca.
So then I set about checking out various Christian denominations. Wow! There are a TON of them. It's like going to one of those all-you-can-eat buffets. Anyways, most seemed to have very nice people but theologocally lacking in something I was looking for. For me, Christ comes first (meaning the principles of love thy neighbor, etc), then the acceptance of the scientific reality, works of charity and mercy, the 'free-to-be-me' attitude (I refuse to wear a tie again, unless absolutely necessary), and then somewhere down the line perhaps the Bible.
It was tough to find one, so I decided to back to college and study religious thought and theology. I picked both non-denom protestant and Catholic universities to get both sides of the coin. Still learning, but discovering that the Catholic Church is nothing like what I thought it was, or even what many cradle catholics think it is. I can be both an evolutionist and a catholic if I want! That's cool to me.
So, still investigating, but that's where I am in my seeking since walking away from the jw.
**PS: Sorry for such a long post.
edited for spelling *sigh