The Watchtower story that Rutherford's father opposed his pursuit of higher education and that young Joe had to take out a loan to hire replacement to work on his father's farm while he was away at school has no historical basis. True the senior Rutherford at the time was expanding his farm and adding a new well, but this work was completed before Joe went off to school. Though Rutherford never attended the University, he did attend a teachers college, or normal school as they were called in those days, for one year. Joe's older sisters were school teachers and no doubt they encouraged him in this field. Thus in March 1888 he was hired to teach elementry school in Syracuse, Missouri. He proved to be a popular teacher and well liked by the school board. Nevertheless, young Joe did not pursue a career in the field of public education.
In November 1889 Joe took the examination for court stenographer in Morgan County and passed with flying colors. The law required applicants to be able to write 600 words in shorthand in five minutes. Rutherford wrote 600 words in three and one half minutes. He got the job and that was the beginning of his legal and political career.
My book has an entire chapter on Rutherford's education and unlike the Watchtower history book, all my sources are footnoted and documented.
So both the Watchtower and its critics are wrong regarding Rutherford's education. True he never attended university or law school, but he did have a year of higher education, a year that he used wisely to learn the skills that he would need in the fields of public education, politics, and religion.