They have basically told the JW how they ought to feel regarding voting. They, in reality, have not left much, if any, room for the conscience to actually work.
If I'm not mistaken, the same position is taken on holidays and birthdays. I don't think they come right out and say it is a disfellowshipping matter. However, once again, I think that they take the same route, which is telling the JW's how they Ought to act and feel towards the holidays and birthday celebrations.
In this way, they have successfully manipulated a person's feelings on the matter and further, if a person actually chooses to vote or celebrate a holiday or day of birth, and this becomes known to the congregation, the congregation can "mark" the person.
Conscience my ass.
Right but if I recall when I was young marking was just the same. Later when we had talks saying we were not to publicly mark someone...it was done hush hush and the person was treated as if df'ed. Still the same. Might as well have been as dead to the congregation as I am. My brother keeps saying the congregation has changed....but until they come back and say...we were WRONG. WE WERE wrong and clear the name and all the names of the people they f***ed over, I cannot see how they have changed at all. This admit no fault thing is full of crap. For instance.
Say back in 1975 a family left because of all the BS. Well the family's family still left in looks at them and looks down at them as if to say...oh they are the ones that left because they were not so humble, they did not have the right attitude. I really feel the society should clear it up. So that the family who saw through the BS could be looked on by their family as being a bit ahead of the times. Smart, a pioneer so to speak, a freethinker.
Times have changed. If whole countries can change and whole regimes can fall and customs can end and the world around the JW's can grow up..why oh why can't they? It is not so damn hard to say...We were wrong. We like anyone else do not have all the answers, but we do strive to serve God the best we can, we have a lot of healing to do, and we will provide the best resourses we can to do this.
I cannot see the WTS falling from that. People are silly they won't give up their faith overnight...but why not start over and give them a fresh and healed faith if you REALLY are there for the people and care about your sheep. (so to speak)
This is madness.