Are the American People Lost?

by sammielee24 11 Replies latest jw friends

  • sammielee24
    sammielee24

    This is an article from Michael Moore's website that I found really good in summary.

    He was on CNN with Wolf Blitzer and he was phenomenal! Took Wolfie down like a cougar on a quail! The man rocks!! sammieswife.

    July 8th, 2007 5:02 pm
    After 'Sicko,' old American ideals seem lost

    By George Kennedy / The Missourian

    When I read the Declaration of Independence in the Missourian on the morning of our 231st birthday, I had to wonder whether ­— amidst parades, cookouts and fireworks — we’ve forgotten something important.

    That’s the part where Mr. Jefferson and his fellow traitors to the Crown declare that they’ve had enough, that revolution is required and that they’re all in it together. Remember that last, spine-tingling line? “... We mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes and our sacred Honor.”

    So I went to the movies. My life’s companion and I saw “Sicko,” Michael Moore’s latest. If you haven’t seen it yet, you should. There’s at least a chance, I think, that, like Al Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth,” this is a film that will change the public conversation, maybe even public policy.

    You know the story line: After introducing us to a variety of victims of our current health care system, Mr. Moore takes his cameras and his audience to examine some alternatives. He visits Canada, Great Britain and France, all of which have government-run systems that produce better results at lower cost than ours. In the grand finale, he gathers three of the many rescue workers from Sept. 11 who’ve been labeled heroes while being denied adequate medical care, along with some of the others, and takes them to Cuba, where they receive what appears to be compassionate, effective — and free — treatment.

    If you’ve only read the reviews, you probably don’t realize that in this film more than his previous works, such as “Bowling for Columbine” and “Fahrenheit 9/11,” Mr. Moore is striving for empathy rather than outrage. He lays a credible foundation of the facts we already know — how we spend more and get less care than any other developed country, and how the big money of the insurance companies and drug companies perverts policy making. In a tone more of sadness than anger, he shows us the real stories of real victims of the system we tolerate.

    As the lights came up, I was left wondering how much truth there was in the explanation one Frenchman offered for the differences between his country’s all-inclusive, taxpayer-supported system and ours, in which denying care and maximizing profit seem to be the objects of the enterprise. In France, he said, the government fears the people; in the United States, it’s the other way around.

    An old English left-wing politician suggested another possible cause. Britain’s National Health Service, he recalled, was created after WWII, a time of shared sacrifice and shared commitment. Real democracy is required for real change, he said.

    Could it be that we’ve become a people so self-centered, so self-satisfied, or maybe so apathetic and even cowed, that we refuse to see the need for a health care revolution when it stares us in the face? Is our political system so corrupted by the legalized bribery that finances unending election cycles that it is incapable of responding to a crisis so evident and so critical?

    The essential question is the one Mr. Moore poses near the end of the film. As a people, who are we, anyway? Is that pledge of 1776 still relevant? Or is it just a historical relic to be recalled once a year?

    George Kennedy is a former managing editor for the Columbia Missourian and a professor emeritus at the Missouri School of Journalism.

  • zeroday
    zeroday
    This is an article from Michael Moore's website

    You don't need to say anything more...

  • sammielee24
    sammielee24
    You don't need to say anything more...

    If you didn't read the article (which also shows up on numerous other sites - I just stumbled across it on his) then you do a disservice to the writer. You might do a disservice to yourself as well, since the writer poses the question wether or not Americans are too self centered, too apathetic and even too cowed and the unwillingness of people to even think about those questions in any context speaks for itself. I thought the guy wrote the article very well. sammieswife.

  • IP_SEC
    IP_SEC

    Yes, but you are right sam MM is only part of the problem. At least he questions authority.

  • bigdreaux
    bigdreaux

    i usually can't go with 1 word mr. moore says, but, i agree with him on this. we need a revolution. the silent majority needs to be heard. our medical system is a joke.

  • moshe
    moshe

    The United States was set up to give people the freedom to make money by being unfettered by governmant as much as possible. Now that our natural resources are rapidly dwindling we much face up to the facts,ie.- capitalists must give way to conservationists or we are all doomed to become serfs to the multi-billionaire barons and corporations of the world.

  • Anti-Christ
    Anti-Christ
    The United States was set up to give people the freedom to make money by being unfettered by government as much as possible. Now that our natural resources are rapidly dwindling we much face up to the facts,ie.- capitalists must give way to conservationists or we are all doomed to become serfs to the multi-billionaire barons and corporations of the world.

    I think I never heard American styled politics so well summarized.

  • stillajwexelder
    stillajwexelder

    Are the American People Lost?

    Well their Geogrpahy is so crap I am not suprised tehy are lost

  • CaptainSchmideo
    CaptainSchmideo

    The name of the Leftist British Politician was Tony Benn, and I'd like to quote two things he said in the movie:

    Tony Benn: Keeping people hopeless and pessimistic - see I think there are two ways in which people are controlled - first of all frighten people and secondly demoralize them.
    Tony Benn: An educated, healthy and confident nation is harder to govern.

    And that is it in a nutshell. Many people I know that are members of "the working class" are so discouraged when they try so hard to make a decent living:nice house, family, some kind of future; but instead it just seems like one obstacle after another cuts the legs right out from them. So we all become pessimistic, disheartened, hopeless.

    The lesser of two evils gets elected, we KNOW nothing's going to change, we KNOW that things won't get better, we KNOW that politicians lie, and we KNOW that the system is rigged. So we hunker down, we don't rock the boat, we don't make waves, because we don't want to be singled out for special attention or trouble.

    And when we get to that level, then the powers-that-be have us right where they want us.

    Come to think of it, that's how the WTS keeps control as well, by frightening and demoralizing the members. If the Dubs were "educated, healthy, and confident", how many of them would stay as Dubs? How much crap could the Society get away with, then?

    I enjoyed the movie. I don't believe 100% as fact, but I walked away with this: The health systems in England, France, and Cuba are not perfect, Magical Gum-Drop Land, solutions. However, the fact is, such programs do exist, and they seem to work for the majority of the people. In the US, where I am paying $500.00 a month for insurance that still requires that I pay additional fees at the doctor's, plus only covers 80% of my expenses (which means if I have a bill that costs $50,000.00 (which is NOT far-fetched!) for a serious illness, I "only" have to pay $12,000), you can still be DENIED care by your insurance carrier if they deem it "unnecessary" or "experimental". And if you don't have insurance, good luck, Fella!

    Some people moan about the amount of taxes they would pay for such a program. Well, $500.00 a month IS a tax, except I pay it to a private business instead of the government. I would gladly shift that amount to a different destination, if the end result would be similar to Canada's or England's.

    Just ask any Canadian or Brit if they would like to trade medical programs with the average working US citizen, see what they say. First, you might have to wait for the hysterical laughter to die down.....

  • Anti-Christ
    Anti-Christ
    Just ask any Canadian or Brit if they would like to trade medical programs with the average working US citizen, see what they say. First, you might have to wait for the hysterical laughter to die down.....

    Hahahahahahahahaha!!!! To answer your question, no.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit