This past weeks assignment in Rev. Climax was largely an exercise in explaining light and brighter light on this. Chapter 20 para 1-5, and there are interesting differences in the different editions used in the group I attend. Mine says copyright 1988, 2006 printing. And the answer is still less clear than primordial mud. The talk "The World Has Ended -- Millions Living Now Will Never Die" is mentioned, says it is updated by Vindication, Book One, 1931 and further explained in Vindication Book Two, 1932. As best I can tell, the sheep class, briefly called the Jehonadab class, are to be preserved through the time of Armageddon and given everlasting life on earth. "In 1934 The Watchtower made it clear that these Christians with earthly hopes should make a dedication to Jehovah and be baptized." Oh my. What about those who die while waiting? Or already died while waiting before 1934? Or who aren't dedicated to Jah and baptized by the WTTS? It doesn't say. The teach book waffles as well, but I found this in the Appendix, pp214, 215. "To live forever, both Armageddon survivors and resurrected ones will have to obey God's commandments, including whatever new requirements Jehovah might reveal during the thousand years." The thousand years of Judgment Day, that is. Sheesh, I guess I don't get it.