Did you tell them you found that most here felt they have been abused, stumbled and treated badly, by "evil slaves" and that you were researching the best way to bring us back into the fold. That not all are DFd. Did you keep record of your time spent here (so you can report it). Did you remind them that the WTBS has been telling us for years to expand preaching avenues. Mass mailing, cold calls, storefront/ mall witnessing and the very rare impromptu witness. Certainly in an age of Information reaching out to such stumbled souls should include the various media outlets. Did not the early FDS use phonographs. Why not start avidly expanding the preaching medium to include the internet, ads that run before the previews of movies, TV commercials (Damn the LDS they beat us to that one!) , maybe another documentary or a sit-com (after all the legal dept wants us to appear mainstream anyway) etc etc.......
Did you explain that fishing for men is easier if you know where a stocked pond is located. That you felt you could get such ones to contact their local KH so as to start studying again! That you were "following the Christ" by looking to call on the unrighteous. Above all this, to assume such awful things about you shows a lack of faith in you and their sheparding skills.
I strongly suggest you arrange a meeting with these blabber mouth elders as well as at least 2 more elders from your congregation. Explain how disappointing and stumbling such behavior is to any sheep. Defend yourself with the above arguements.
If of course none of the above is your actual feelings...then consider it "Theocratic Warfare", telling only those who deserve to know the truth.........(if Eldums are are going to slander you....are they deserving to know the truth?)
Finally I have posted it many times but.....
Paul said in 1Cor 7:23 "to stop becoming slaves to men" surely no elder could refute such fine Biblical counsel from one of the Original FDS!