My Story, Chaper 5 - "They're making this sh*& up!"

by B_Deserter 12 Replies latest jw friends

  • B_Deserter
    B_Deserter

    Shortly after I received my Associates Degree, I quit pioneering. I told the body of elders is was because my mother had fallen on some hard times, and I needed to get a full-time job to support the family. They asked me if it was because I felt bad for not having gas money. I said no, but that was a lie. Every day I'd go out in service, the older pioneer couple would bitch and complain about people that didn't donate for gas. They would say how those people don't appreciate what it takes to chauffeur people around every day. They even complained about people when they only donated $1, because that wasn't enough. Ever since my seasonal job ended, I just didn't have the money to donate for gas. I was tired of being indirectly reminded of what a horrible person I was for not donating.

    The day I came home and realized that I would have had a better day had I not gone out in service, I realized that I couldn't continue pioneering. My mother always told me that if I don't feel like going to the meetings or service, I should make myself go, because I'll always be glad I went. It just wasn't true for me. Sometimes it was, but there was nothing like the feeling of staying in instead of going to the meeting.

    I got my first full-time job a few months after I stopped pioneering. I worked there for three years, but I got laid off multiple times. The second time, I started looking for another job and I got one, across the state. Within a month I had moved to a nice suburb of Detroit. The congregation there was really nice, but I didn't make a connection with anyone. Instead, I started hanging out with a person from work. I got into a table-top game called Warhammer 40,000. It was a little uncomfortable at first, but I eventually got used to it. More people from work invited me to do stuff, but I resisted. I wasn't going to go to the bar, that much was sure.

    I never settled into the new congregation, and missed a lot of meetings. I only went in service a total of 2 or 3 times the year I was there. I was still a Jehovah's Witness at heart, but wrestled with depression and the guilt over missing meetings. There was also a lot of pressure at work that I wasn't used to. A friend I had in the northern part of the state had me convinced my job and the hustle-and-bustle of the city was causing my depression, and he invited me to live with him, share expenses, work part time, and serve Jehovah. I jumped at the chance, and put in my notice two months early. My last day of work, I saw Alien vs. Predator in the theater with three guys from work and my brother. It was a good time. I felt relieved at the same time because I'd no longer be put in a situation where I'd have to decline a social occasion with them on religious grounds.

    I lived for a year in Traverse City with my friend. It was good at first, but the pressure to find a job was intense, and there were no jobs to be had up there. I wanted a simple, part-time job that allowed me to insure and gas my car, and pay my share of the lot rent at the trailer park. Because of my technical background, it was hard to find a job with that kind of security. At the first few jobs I had, the hours got cut back drastically, completely negating the point of having a job in the first place. I finally found steady employment, but my dealings with my roommate soured, and I eventually moved back home with my parents. I started going to the congregation in which I grew up, with limited success. One fateful night alone at book study, it all fell apart for me.

    We were studying the book "Pay Attention to Daniel's Prophecy!" The week's lesson was on the king of the north and king of the south prophecy. The book explained that there were more than one king of the north and king of the south, and proceeded to list them all throughout history. My thoughts began to race, trying desperately to find the logic, but I couldn't. This elaborate interpretation was nothing more than wishful thinking, I realized. If Daniel meant that there were multiple Kings of the north and south, wouldn't he have just said so? It hit me hard, and it hit me fast, "The society is making this shit up!"

    Months later, I started looking more into different explanations of the Bible, then of criticisms of the Bible itself. I learned things I never knew before, and I realized something else: it was forbidden for me to research this. I started to disagree with the fundamentals of how the society itself operated, practicing information control and demonizing all thought that doesn't originate with the organization.

    I talked to my mom about it. "Brian, you're just depressed," she said. I resent my mother to this day for that. She's never taken me seriously. If I disagree with her, it's a problem with me. I tried to bring up some objections, only to be met with "that's apostate thinking! Besides, who cares if the society isn't right about that little thing?" I care, but I also realize that she is too far gone to "get it." I eventually decided to fade, since my brother who is a witness lives with me and making a break is just not possible. Eventually, I plan to move from the city and complete my fade. I'm just going to start living as a regular person. I'm not interested in turning other people away from the religion. I just don't agree with it, plain and simple.

  • Hortensia
    Hortensia

    I often had that experience - everything I said was discounted because I must be depressed, or have pms, or be "stumbled" or whatever. No one ever acknowledged that I might actually feel the way I said I felt, and believe what I said I believed. I couldn't get angry, because it just proved I wasn't faithful enough, or willing to wait on whatsisname, or obedient enough to "mother" or I wasn't out in service enough. No one ever acknowledged I had things to be angry about, justifiably.

  • compound complex
    compound complex

    Thank you, B_Deserter, for this well-written and compelling account.

    This fabrication of "truth," presented as bona fide history, is what we based our entire lives upon. We were told that these were God's words. Only now am I am to see the truth of what you saw early on.

    It's all so clear now.

    Gratefully,

    CoCo

  • shell69
    shell69

    Hortensia; your response was much more eloquent that I could have mannaged but my feelings are identical.

    Just feel you cannot win with these people.

    Shell69

  • nomoreguilt
    nomoreguilt

    It's all just one BIG shell game.

    NMG

  • kitten whiskers
    kitten whiskers

    Isn't it amazing how that happens! I think I was in the same book when I started pulling it apart too. I remember all the anti-type stuff they would say in the bookstudy and I thought the same thing you did. This is cr@p! It's just a bunch of made up ideas. Well, I guess being faithful and making it to bookstudy paid off for both of us!

    Oh... and don't forget this foreshadowed that and so on and so on. I can't believe they have the guts to study the Revelation book and add four pages of changes to it! I hope more people have true "revelations" as they go over this recycled rubbish! Hopefully their reasoning will kick in and they too can climb out. You sound like a nice person and very honest. I feel bad for you and your situation. We're from Michigan too, and when you said you moved up to Traverse City my first thought was "what in the world did you find as work up there? Cherry picking? " The Michigan economy forced us out and I hear they are leaving by the droves! Here's to you for sticking it out and working on your fade! You are still nice and young and made it out 8 years faster than my hubby and me! Congratulations and best wishes! Life is great out here in the normal world. We were lied to about so many, many things growing up as JW's. I hope you find much happiness and joy in your life! PM me if you like. It's nice to see someone break out in the prime of their life!

  • R.Crusoe
    R.Crusoe

    That is so encouraging for others to read B Deserter! And the Daniel stuff about a trumpet blast being a talk in England was also a bullĀ£$%&

    notion! It makes you realise why they don't tell you the 'meat' of the word before baptism. They know if they told you the WHOLE truth first you would never go with the flow and decide you had an obligation to convert others to such claptrap!!

    Oh and the stuff about mother saying 'apostate' thinking and accept bits here n there as wrong is far more soul searching than I ever fully understood.

    EXCUSE me ladies for pitching this at females because I know some males think along the same lines! Just I know many a female who reasons this way!!

    The idea that something can be the absolute truth with tolerated extras that you know are wrong just does not add up. And to reason that you take the best and leave the rest for a simple life whilst going round telling others about 'divine' connections is boloney!.And saying how you can't do one thing or another because it will spoil your own happiness and acceptance by others is to selfishly reason to follow 'truth' under completely false pretenses.

    I met many people who do exactly that - say they fully believe or support something and play the whole game whilst in their mind and heart they know absolutely that they are making concessions they will never openly discuss with you -asking you to tell them everything whilst they keep quiet about their inner thoughts and then trying to tell you how you should be. I detest such thinking!!

    Great you realise any God you feel is in you and not any books anywhere on Earth. All books do is give you an idea what someone else believed when they were alive - so read and learn if you wish - you may find they have had feelings you had as well as ones you didn't. Just tune into yourself and don't accept what you don't feel - especially when it comes full of attachments you don't need! God certainly doesn't expect you to otherwise millions of starving would have books by their sides! It's inside you and given to you as a life form to wonder at nature!

    It's as much as many of us can be sure about and any God who might exist already knows it!

  • dawg
    dawg

    Have you ever thought your brother knows its crap and is too afraid to speak justlike you? Have you ever dropped him a line.

  • B_Deserter
    B_Deserter

    My brother wanted to leave not too long ago, but he got swept up by this new congregation. He's studying now and the things he's saying in the study are incredibly stupid and ignorant. On the other hand, he's having a tough time with the whole literature/Bible thing. He's studying with a girl right now and she wanted to use her own Bible and not the NWT and also only the Bible and no literature. Obviously, he's being pushed to include literature by my parents. He just became a publisher and finished with the Bible Teach book.
    I try to discuss how I feel about stuff with him in an indirect way. I have to be very careful about being openly against the Witnesses, but I can say a few things that go against the norm a little.

  • B_Deserter
    B_Deserter
    when you said you moved up to Traverse City my first thought was "what in the world did you find as work up there? Cherry picking? "

    I wasn't that fortunate! I ended up having to work retail for my duration up there, but spent a good few months unemployed, too."

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit