Leander,
I'm glad you posted. My husband and share many, many of the same questions and concerns. I don't know what the solution is. I guess I keep hoping for a reform of sorts. Maybe if enough of us go strictly by the Bible and refuse to believe or teach the extra rules thrown in by man, we can make a difference for the good. That might be naive, but that's what I'm hoping for.
I know, it's discouraging. My husband used to be an MS and isn't now. He hasn't been to a meeting in 6 weeks. I still go, but considering how I used to be (pioneeer, went where need was great, etc.), I'm at a pretty low spiritual ebb right now. The lowest ever.
I share your confusion. Problems inside; doesn't feel right to leave either though. I still feel like it's God's organization, though maybe it has somehow drifted into a state where Jehovah might be feeling disapproval with it. (Like how the Israelites kept drifting off the mark, and then even in the first century too). So I keep wondering what Jehovah would have me do. Leave, or stay even though I know things are off kilter (like David, when he wouldn't strike out against Saul, the anointed of Jehovah - trusting that He will take care of things in His own way and time???)
For now, I'm stayin in, holding on, and holding out. In a kind of spiritual limbo. Really feeling good about some aspects of being a Witness, about the major doctrines, etc., but also seeing things in the congregation that also go terribly wrong. I don't try to sway my hubby either way. Whatever decision he makes, I want it to be his own.
In conclusion, what to do? What to doooooooooooooooooooooooooooo?
I don't feel qualified to give you advice, Leander. Except maybe to say "Don't make any quick decisions. Weigh things thoroughly." That's what I'm trying to do.
Leander, I'm glad you posted. I really am. Please know that you are not the only currently active JW struggling with these kinds of issues and questions. I can't help but think, in time, that things will become clearer, one way or the other.