I have never been a JW so as others have said take what I say with a grain of salt but I think I have something to add to this discussion.
About me, I’m what you here would call a “born again”. I accepted Jesus as my Lord and Savior in 1977. In 1980 I was baptized Presbyterian. From about 1982 till about 1988, I didn’t attend any church and had limited Bible reading. My wife (who was raised in a Catholic family) oddly enough wanted to start going to church and picked a Lutheran Church. We went there for about 3 years, during that time I did a lot of study on the reformation and Luther the man. After about 2 years I was asked to serve as a trustee which I did. Towards the end of our 3 years, I finally realized that the church was too far removed from the teaching of the Bible and Luther. For reference, this church was an ELCA church. There are Lutheran churches that do hold to the historic teachings of Lutheranism, but not the one we went to. We left and looked around for something more Bible based. After many visits about, we settled on a Baptist church.
One thing that makes a Baptist church Baptist is that the local church is autonomous. That means that if you use the Southern Baptist for example, church A may be liberal, church B may be fundamental, church C may be Calvinistic, church D may be Free Will and on and on, all Southern Baptist though. Some of these churches may be heavy into Bible; others may be into keeping rules for life (legalistic). The only way to know is to inquire.
The other thing to know is that there are independent churches that are what is called “Baptistic”. They agree with Baptist doctrine however they do not call themselves Baptist. While I personally consider myself Baptist, I, like a previous poster in this thread (JeffT) attend an Evangelical Free Church. A conservative Baptist would feel very at home in an Evangelical Free Church. Calvary Chapel is also close to this kind of theology but more modern. I do not know much about AOG or the like so I cannot comment.
Then there are the “Mainline Protestant Churches”. These churches IN GENERAL are not as Bible based and are more liberal. The ELCA (Evangelical Lutheran Church in America) is a good example. American Baptist Churches in the USA is another, but again, some local churches may be more conservative then the majority.
A point I want to make here is this. Even an experienced Baptist/Evangelical/Conservative/Fundamental church goer like myself gets a little weak in the knees when going to a new church for the first time. I know what to expect and I know what I want in a church but still I get nervous. We moved to PA in 2004 and it took 3 years to find a good church home. The main thing though is this (in my opinion), does the local church teach the Bible as the word of God and is Jesus the center of attention?
As I have mentioned in previous threads, it should be OK for the individual church goer to disagree with some points of doctrine. Of course there should be more points of agreement than disagreement, but this is where a study of theology comes in handy. I’m surprised but happy to hear that some of you are looking to find a church post-WT. Being a church goer or member should not be a chore, it should be a time of refreshment and instruction in the Bible, worship and fellowship.