I have heard pumps that are rigged will dispense 5 or 10 gallons exactly correctly (since those are the amounts auditors check), but will cheat you on other amounts of fuel. Seems a tad far fetched to me.
Come on now ... "seems a tad far fetched to me." ???
It's just a matter of programming the computer chip to display whatever amount you want as the gas is flowing. The pump is still pumping the same, it's just the amount that is displaying that is modified.
I recall one case about a year ago where a gas station was busted for an illegal chip.
If you purchased under 5 gallons or any multple of 5 gallons (10, 15, 20, etc) the amount of fuel would be correct. After the first 5 gallons, it would slow slightly so that at the mid-points (7.5, 12.5, etc.) you would get ripped off the most (about a quart). By the time it would get to the next 5 gallon multiple, it would have "caught up" and displayed the proper amount. It was even programmed to "steal" more fuel based on your purchasing more (so if you thought you were buying 12.5 gallons, you were losing like 2 quarts).
The guy who got busted confessed that there is a big market for this type of thing and the chips are made to order based on how you want it to overcharge the buyers.
Rub a Dub