Is "free will" really free, if you are punished for making the "wrong" choice?
According to the JW interpretation of the Bible, man was perfect until he sinned - then God punished him by somehow removing that perfection - unplugged the fan, as it were, to use the old "Live Forever" illustration.
If a robber holds a gun to my head and says "your money or your life", technically I have free will to refuse to give him my money - but in practical terms, I really have no choice.
Technically, Adam had "free will" to obey or disobey God - but when he made the choice that displeased God, God punished him. How "free" was that free will?