Farkel
You are correct. Separating out the pieces makes it difficult.
Spiritual abuse invades the mind and the soul.
Physical abuse attacks the body, and invades the mind and the soul.
Sexual abuse invades the body, the mind, and the soul.
Having gone through all of them and some before I was a JW I can say there is a difference.
My family was filled with violence pre-JW. I grew up in an atmosphere of fear. That was the first strike for my self-esteem. I knew I could be attacked and perhaps killed by my father. I was "stupid and would never amount to anything" I deserved the beatings I got or so I was told and what else was there for me to believe. My mind was attacked with insults and my body attacked with anything handy.
Being sexually abused before the JW certainly added another blow. My body was no longer mine. Things were done to it, places touched and prodded, all despite my protestations and tears. Lesson: You are here for my purpose alone. When. Where. and How. You have nothing to say about it because you are nothing. Men who demand your body have all rights to it. (That one led to abuse by several other men in my life between the ages of 8-11)
When my father was caught he was arrested. He always told me the police would arrest me because I was doing something wrong. What a surprise to watch the police handcuff him and put him in the cruiser. Lesson: Maybe I didn't deserve it.
Then we get involved with the JWs. I was 11 and hungry for affection. Belonging. And I got it. I even asked to be baptized but they said I was too young. Lesson: Not good enough.
Then more physical abuse and more sexual abuse. Lessons: You are nothing. Your body is solely for the enjoyment of men. They can touch you and feel you and do things to you and you have no right to say no. 4 men doing what they want and I have no say.
Then I was sent to foster care because of the sexual abuse. Lesson: You are nothing. You don't deserve a family. You wanted this and now you are being punished for it. And my foster mother made sure to remind me every day what a dirty little girl I was.
Then back to my mother and more physical abuse and I got baptized. At 17 I got my last beating from her. Lesson: I still OWN you. Getting baptized meant the WTS OWNED me. Everything I did was in relation to the WTS. Now my life was not my own. Not my mind. Not my body.
Then she arranged for me to marry. Lesson: I will transfer ownership to someone else. Now he will OWN you.And due to their stupid rules about marriage and submission not my sexuality.
So now I am doubly owned. My body, my mind, my spirit. Nothing belongs to me. I am nothing. And I am reminded of my place. Both at home and at the hall.
On top of this there is one more type of abuse - political. I was living in Quebec where English speaking people are treated like second class citizens. We can't walk into a store and be greeted in English. Sometimes we can't get services in English. If you don't speak French jobs are hard to get. English people are second-class citizens. Lesson: If you live here you are a non-person undeserving of basic freedoms that French-speaking people have.
Layers. Each type of abuse has its own issues. Each teaches a lesson in self-esteem. Each eroded the self a bit more until I was left feeling like death was the only way out. Nothing. I was worth nothing. My body was worth nothing. Anything I did was worth nothing.
Even I think it is amazing I got out of it all.