It's way too overblown and way too stupid in many cases. If a person is tipping for service, then why the hell are you putting a percentage on the price of the meal? I mean, let's face it - I go to a restaurant and order a $40.00 meal that includes a bottle of cheap wine ...the staff expect a 20% tip on that....I sit on the other side of the restaurant and order a meal for $200.00 that includes a more expensive bottle of wine and yet the staff expect a 20% tip. Tipping on the price of the meal makes no sense simply because the time spent uncorking the wine takes the same number of minutes - walking a steak out of the kitchen vs walking a burger out of the kitchen takes up the same amount of time ...placing the plate on your table - the same amount of time and focus. Nothing different but the price of the meal and theoretically, you could have the same waiter, performing the exact same service, in the same restaurant and yet expect to pay him more in a larger tip, simply because you ate a meal that cost you more. That is not tipping on service - it's tipping on the cost of your meal.
So it would appear that tipping a wait staff based on the price of the meal has little to do with the service but with the cost of the meal...and realistically, many a meal has been overpriced.
Tipping a person as Starbucks for making your coffee? Why? Is the coffee supposed to be better for tipping the maker an extra buck? Drive through windows at Micky D's? Some tip there - why? So a guy can hand you a burger in a bag that you just ordered through a microphone and got in a paper bag? The hair dresser who also happens to own the salon she is working in? She's self employed - are we saying that she'll screw up your hair if you don't tip her? What about the cabby? You pay him for a safe and quick ride to the airport - doesn't his cab fare include the presumption that he is professional and will provide that ride safely and quickly without a tip?
I think it's unfair to label one group of people cheaper or less sensitive to the issue of tipping if they don't fit the 'norm'.
I've been a tipper but the more I think about it, the more I think I need to rethink the whole tipping issue. sammieswife.