Unchanging TRUTH changes from 1939--thru--2000

by Terry 15 Replies latest jw friends

  • Terry
    Terry

    Here is a strange premise. God speaks through you, but, you make errors. When your errors are pointed out it means you have been blessed!

    The fact that what you have publicly declared to be God Speaking Through You has been WRONG and needs correcting is viewed as evidence of being blessed.

    Examples:

    "Changes in viewpoint that took place up to 1939:

    • 1921 - Vaccines are banned
    • 1927 - "Faithful and Discreet Slave" is identified as a group of Christians and not an individual
    • 1927 - Celebration of Christmas and birthdays banned
    • 1928 - Great pyramid of Giza has nothing to do with God's purpose
    • 1929 - "Superior authorities" of Romans 13:1 identified as Jehovah God and Jesus Christ
    • 1930
      • All of Russell's dates were changed, the majority to commence in, rather than be completed by 1914
      • Moved beginnning of Christ's Second Coming from 1874 to 1914
      • Moved Christ's enthronement as King from 1878 to 1914
      • Moved the beginning of the resurrection of the "Bride of Christ" from 1878 to 1918
      • Moved start of last days from 1799 to 1914
      • Moved Armageddon from 1914 to within a generation, with the understanding of generation changing several times
    • 1931 - Adoption of the name 'Jehovah's Witnesses'
    • 1932 - Application of restoration prophecies to Christian congregation, rather than to the literal Jews
    • 1935 - Identity of "great crowd" of Revelation 7
    • 1936 - Use of the cross as a religious symbol banned
    • 1938 - Communion bread and wine identified as symbols of the body and blood of the 144,000
    • 1939 - Complete neutrality in worldly affairs

    Significant Changes in Doctrine1944—2000:

    • 1944 - Disfellowshipping (although this had already been practised in some form earlier)
    • 1945 - Blood transfusion forbidden (clarification of existing stance on blood and specific application to transfusions)
    • 1952 - Vaccines allowed. It was clarified that the Witnesses' position on blood does not apply to vaccination (some Witnesses were already accepting vaccinations at least as early as World War II) (Watchtower 15 December1952)
    • 1954 - Jesus no longer to be worshiped (though the Watch Tower legal charter still states that the organisation exists to promote the worship of Jehovah and Jesus)
    • 1956 - Communion bread and wine identified as symbols of Christ's body and blood (return to pre-1938 position)
    • 1962 - "Superior authorities" of Romans 13:1 identified as earthly governments (Watchtower 15 November1962)
    • 1967 - Organ transplants classed as "cannibalism" (Watchtower 15 November1967)
    • 1973 - Tobacco use viewed as incompatible with membership (it had been strongly discouraged throughout the prior history of the organization) (Watchtower 1 June1973)
    • 1980 - Organ transplants acceptable
    • 1995 - Meaning of the term "this generation" referred to at Matthew 24:34 restored to a class of people displaying certain characteristics. (Matthew 17:17) (Watchtower 1 November1995)
    • 1995 - Time of fulfillment of Jesus' parable of the sheep and the goats (Watchtower 1 February1995)
    • 2000 - Fractions derived from blood are deemed permissable and left up to conscience of individual Witness

    If there is little doubt that Jehovah's Witnesses have changed some of their doctrines over the past century, there is considerable controversy in some quarters over the significance of the changes.Watch Tower literature recognizes that doctrinal changes have taken place though it states:

    "Matters on which corrections of viewpoint have been needed have been relatively minor when compared with the vital Bible truths that they have discerned and publicized." (Reasoning from the Scriptures, page 136-137)

    Thus, Jehovah's Witnesses' publications, while recognizing that adjustments have been made, emphasize that the core elements of their belief are constant. They maintain that their understanding of the Bible gets clearer at the proper time, just as the understanding of doctrine among Christ's first-century disciples was also clarified gradually.

    Witnesses see these changes as evidence of divine blessing on their efforts to understand the Bible."

  • dgp
    dgp

    Well, the recent change in the meaning of "generation" is not a minor one. I don't expect them to recognize so, however.

  • cantleave
    cantleave

    Nice history lesson Terry. This is a keeper.

  • sd-7
    sd-7

    When Jesus was enthroned as King--minor.

    Whether or not you can get that vaccine for your child--minor. (Unless you get polio, then it's not minor.)

    Whether or not you can get an organ transplant--minor. (Unless you need an organ transplant, then it's not so minor.)

    What the bread and wine represent at the Lord's evening meal--minor.

    The identity of the 'faithful slave'--minor!

    Whether or not people living today will see Armageddon--minor.

    When the last days started--minor.

    When the resurrection begins--minor.

    When the dividing of the 'sheep' and 'goats' takes place--minor.

    Well, I'm convinced.

  • rocketman
    rocketman

    The WTS includes the teaching of 1914 being the beginning of the Time of The End as one of their core teachings. Yet, look at all the changes in regard to 1914. Yet, they assert that such changes are "minor".

  • RR
    RR

    1938 - Communion bread and wine identified as symbols of the body and blood of the 144,000

    Can you clarify this Terry. Are you saying the Society taught that the bread and wine DID NOT reprsent Jesus body and blood, but instead the 144,000 only? If so, any references?

  • Terry
    Terry

    RR asked:

    1938 - Communion bread and wine identified as symbols of the body and blood of the 144,000

    Can you clarify this Terry. Are you saying the Society taught that the bread and wine DID NOT reprsent Jesus body and blood, but instead the 144,000 only? If so, any references?

    Hey RR--

    I've looked through what files I have on my current laptop and I can't find the links to the information contained in my statement!

    When I originally wrote the opening statement it was about five years ago and I was using another computer which has since died and gone to hell.

    All my research went along with it and the especially important reference links.

    I'll bet somebody out there can come up with when and why the change came about in 1938 and can cite the source. Until then, I just don't remember!

    Thanks for asking!

  • Mad Sweeney
    Mad Sweeney

    My guess is there's a typo (or that the thought is incomplete) and that this might be when they decided that the communion bread and wine were identified as symbols of the body and blood of Christ to be partaken only by the 144,000.

    I'm guessing, but either the change was from literal transsubstantiation to symbolic OR from all Dubs to just the 144K (which would likely need to be clarified at around this time, 1938). Just my guess. Hope someone has references.

  • Terry
    Terry

    The "back of the bus" doctrine seems to have developed as a way of granting special class status for the "anointed".

    Only the older JW's will remember how Dispensational the organizations was in the past.

    There was the various "classes" and the Types and Anti-types woven into the tapestry of JW teaching everywhere you looked.

    The "other sheep" lived on earth while the "anointed" went to heaven.

    It wouldn't be unusual for the Rutherford mind to begin with the central doctrine of Catholicism and plagarize the importance as a ritual and then apply it in an unusual way. Rutherford adapted so many aspects of Catholicism into his own version.

  • drwtsn32
    drwtsn32

    Nice job...thanks Terry

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit