Well, I can't even make the bands I dislike the most fit my own scenario. Like, say, 311--utter tripe: every song, every note, full stop.
I don't seem to have sufficient priveleges to update my bio on this site, but I'm in my early 30's.
littlerockguy: I don't dislike that Stevie Wonder song (never heard it before that I recall), but it just doesn't do anything for me on the first listen-through, whereas Superstition really gets me going--I have to sing along!
So, nobody's experienced the original scenario I described, eh?
EDIT:
it's_me!, I had to look up Cracker's Low, but I remember it now. It's OK to me, not a favorite though, but I gotcha. I liked Silverchair for about a week, and have hated them since--not logical, but there it is. Did they ever have any hit songs outside their (I believe) native Australia, other than that song about the water in the bathroom?