Jourles,
He also made mention of a particular scripture about not just following what the WT says, but doing our own research on these matters. That threw me for a big loop as he seemed to be following his outline to the letter up until reading that scripture. In the back of my mind, I wondered if he actually knows this policy is screwed up too?
No, this is the "out" for the WTBS to say that each individual made up their own mind and were not forced. After all, the WTBS encouraged all to do their own research and make up their own mind. Of course, we know that when you "make up your own mind", your personal conclusion had better match the WTBS'!
Using last years cards does the same thing. They can claim they no longer force people to sign the cards...and a card you signed last year is still legally binding.
Years ago, when I was leaving the JWs, an elder came to my home. We had missed the meeting where the blood cards were given out. BTW, this is the elder whom I felt did not want me DFed. He gave my wife a blood card, then handed me cards for myself and my sons. He said as the head of the house, I decide the blood issue for the kids.
I thought it was a test. Refuse the cards, and a JC is formed. I took the cards and graciously thanked him. He was happy, so I passed the test. After he left, I tore the cards up, and told my wife that the kids get blood. I told her to sign her card if she wanted but that I do not know if I would respect it in an emergency. I did not want her to die. I told her that I honestly did not know what I would do either way.
Richard