Who Would Be Good Judges On American Idol?

by minimus 15 years ago 32 Replies latest 15 years ago jw friends

• 

  minimus 15 years ago

  It looks like the ladies are officially gone along with Simon Cowell.

  Who do you think would make good judges?

  Link
• 

  snowbird 15 years ago

  Usher, Taylor Swift, and Peabo Bryson.

  Syl

  Link
• 

  Think About It 15 years ago

  Glad that Ellen & Kara are gone. Read that Jennifer Lopez & Jessica Simpson are both interested. They both would probably be better than the other girls and would be nice to look at. Have seen that Elton John, Justin Timberlake, Harry Connick Jr. & Brett Michaels are interested in taking Simon's place. I enjoyed when HCJr was the guest mentor and he seemed funny, but would be hard for them to pass up getting Elton John if he wanted the job.

  Think About It

  Link
• 

  minimus 15 years ago

  I'd love Gladys Knight!

  Peabo is a critical guy. I've seen him in concert scold the band. He sounded like an ahole but he probably would be a great fit!

  Unfortunately, they seem more folk rock oriented then soul.

  Link
• 

  FlyingHighNow 15 years ago

  I think Deborah Harry/Blondie would make a great, entertaining judge. Cher. Ozzy and Alice Cooper. Love to see Paul McCartney and Ringo sit in. And hmmmm Steve Windwood, Diana Ross, Ronnie Specter, David Cassidy, Bobby Sherman and Donnie and Marie. Oh yeah and Geddy Lee.

  Link
• 

  minimus 15 years ago

  FHN, I love that list!!

  Link
• 

  minimus 15 years ago

  You need people with a mix of sass, kindness and honesty.

  And I really think it has to be someone who understands music---not a Howard Stern.

  Link
• 

  FlyingHighNow 15 years ago

  From beyond the grave Jimmy Hendrix and Laura Nyro.

  Link
• 

  FlyingHighNow 15 years ago

  Steve Martin. He plays banjo, sings, is funny and he's kind hearted.

  Link
• 

  minimus 15 years ago

  Elton is snippy and moody. That type of personality makes for good entertainment.

  Link