Should Muslims Have to Register in the USA?

by sammielee24 59 Replies latest social current

  • sammielee24
    sammielee24

    That was the question being asked on right wing radio - things are getting strange out there. sammieswife

    -------------

    Right-wing radio station: ‘Gun owners have to register, why not Muslims?’

    Wednesday, September 1st, 2010 -- 6:32 pm

    A conservative talk radio station in San Diego has a pressing question to ask its listeners: Should "practicing Muslims" be "registered" on a national database during a time of war?

    KFMB 760 AM, the San Diego home of such right-wing on-air personalities as Glenn Beck, Sean Hannity and Michael Savage, reportedly asked the question on its Web site Wednesday, according to Ben Dimiero at MediaMatters.

    "During a time of war, should we register as many practicing Muslims as we can find in a national database?" the poll asked.

    Voters were given two options to choose from: "No, it's an invasion of privacy," and "Yes, gun owners have to, why not Muslims?"

    The poll had already been removed from the site as of Wednesday evening.

    MediaMatters' Dimiero reported that, at the time he accessed the poll, 63 percent of respondents had said "yes." (Online polls are unscientific and should not be trusted as an accurate reflection of public opinion.)

    Dimiero argues that the poll is further evidence the conservative media is whipping up an Islamophobic hysteria in the United States.

    "It's worth asking KFMB's hosts whether they are okay with being broadcast on a station that thinks it is open to debate whether or not 'practicing Muslims' should have to register in a 'national database'," he remarks.

    He notes that personalities broadcast on KFMB have expressed similar sentiments in the past. Talk show host Michael Savage, for instance, once argued in favor of banning Muslim immigration, while radio and Fox News personality Glenn Beck described the Muslim community center being planned near Ground Zero as an "Allah tells me to blow up America mosque."

  • mrsjones5
    mrsjones5

    I guess some of us don't learn from history, do we?

    State apologizes to Italian Americans for WWII actions 10,000 Italian Americans were displaced from their homes and thousands more faced restriction and hardships during World War II

    by Sue DremannPalo Alto Online Staff

    The little-known government displacement of 10,000 Italian Americans in California during World War II was acknowledged as "a fundamental injustice" by the state Legislature last Friday (Aug. 20). Some were interned while others were forced to move away from the coasts or had other restrictions on their movements.

    More than 1,500 were reported arrested under an order from President Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

    Legislators in the state Assembly and Senate expressed their "deepest regrets," in passage of Senate Concurrent Resolution 95, which was authored by State Sen. Joe Simitian (D-Palo Alto).

    The resolution will "help repair the damage to the Italian American community, and to discourage the occurrence of similar injustices" in the future, Simitian's office announced. The measure is consistent with action taken in the U.S. Congress earlier in the decade.

    During World War II, the United States government designated more than 100,000 California residents as "aliens" and forced many to leave their homes or endure other hardships. The majority of those targeted were of Japanese descent but 10,000 Italian Americans were also forced to leave their homes.

    Greater numbers were required to carry identification cards, were restricted in their travels and were subject to curfew. In some instances, their property was seized, and their livelihoods, particularly fishing along the coast, were denied.

    Simitian's resolution originated in a proposal from Chet Campanella, a resident of San Jose's Willow Glen neighborhood, as part of the senator's annual "There Oughta Be a Law" contest. Campanella's parents, while not interned, were sebjected to a curfew and searches of their home, he said.

    "We refer to it as the 'untold story' because it was classified. No one was supposed to know about it," Campanella said. "Younger people probably don't know that this ever happened. I love this country, and I think a formal apology is so important to the older people, the survivors, before we die."

    Passage of the resolution "makes me really happy on behalf of grandparents, aunts and uncles, my parents and their friends -- people who were really mistreated during World War II. It's finally coming to an end," he said.

    A report to Congress in November 2001, entitled "A Review of the Restrictions on Persons of Italian Ancestry During World War II," chronicled the injustices against Italian Americans, who at that time were the largest foreign-born group in the United States.

    "The impact of the wartime experience was devastating to Italian American communities in the United States and its effects are still being felt," the congressional report concluded.

    Simitian said, "The treatment during World War II of people who were unjustly considered 'suspicious' because of their ethnic background was a sad chapter for our state. For survivors of that experience and their descendants, I hope this resolution will provide a long-due measure of recognition and respect."

    The resolution addresses a historic event, but Simitian said the issue "has never been more timely. Given America's ongoing conflict abroad, the World War II experience is an important reminder of the need to respect the role and rights of those who have ties abroad."

    Simitian's "There Oughta Be a Law" contest invites constituents to suggest legislation. The winning ideas are introduced as bills. Campanella traveled to Sacramento to testify in support of the resolution in the Senate Rules Committee.

    Simitian said he was particularly moved to seek acknowledgment by the legislature because of the its "regrettable" role in the episode. The legislature's 1943 report of the "Joint Fact-Finding Committee on Un-American Activities in California," commonly referred to as the Tenney Report for its author Sen. Jack Tenney, "was not an effort that reflected particularly well on the legislature," Simitian said.

    Find this article at:
    http://www.PaloAltoOnline.com/news/show_story.php?story_id=17982
  • notverylikely
  • White Dove
    White Dove

    My answer: Why did black people and Japanese not have to register anymore? Because, it's a violation of human rights.

    Islam, like guns, doesn't kill people. People using those things as weapons kill people.

    A kitchen knife is a weapon depending on how it's used.

    Islam is used as a weapon by some as an excuse to kill.

  • Justitia Themis
    Justitia Themis

    Japanese during WW2, Chinese, Germans, etc. We have a long and undistinguished history of letting our baser emotion control during tough times. We like to believe that we have progressed, but only time will tell whether we have.

    It's good to keep in mind the Hitler and Mussolini were elected...because people were experiencing economic down times and wanted these strong personalities to put things 'back on track.' So...they looked the other way at human rights violations.

  • Justitia Themis
    Justitia Themis

    Excellent response:

    http://www.examiner.com/anti-establishment-in-national/75-percent-of-760am-listeners-think-muslims-should-be-forced-to-register-on-a-national-database

    It is no longer extreme, if referring to this particular group of people. Forced registration is exactly what the Nazis did to the Jewish population of Germany.

    The Nazis did not kill 6 million Jewish people overnight and go from being perfectly amicable one day to burning them in ovens the next. It started with small steps. It was certain restrictions or regulations, then it was mandatory yellow stars, then it was curfews; it was the culmination of many smaller civil liberty infringements that eventually led to mass murder in concentration camps.

  • JWoods
    JWoods

    Come on people - surely we all realize that at least 90% of Americans reject such an idea?

  • Justitia Themis
    Justitia Themis

    How would YOU answer JWoods?

  • JWoods
    JWoods

    Do you really have to ask?

  • Justitia Themis
    Justitia Themis

    Do you really have to ask?

    Yes. Answer?

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit