There are plenty of examples in the Bible of righteous men who questioned Jehovah directly. Gideon, Abraham, and Habakkuk questioned God when the evidence in front of their eyes suggested that either what he or his messengers were saying was not true or injustice was prevailing. Did God punish them for asking legitimate questions or label them as blasphemous apostates? No. He either provided hard proof that he was in control or patiently answered their questions.
God created humans with the capacity to reason. Part of reasoning is asking questions. Asking questions and then meaningfully searching for the answers is the only way we can learn anything. If a belief is true, it withstands all forms of inquiry, even the most critical. If a belief is on shaky ground, it is much easier to avoid questioning it than it is to face the possibility that it might be wrong. The Bible is a book that offers a lot of uncertainty, an incomplete picture of the big questions in life. It's hard enough to understand without religious groups overlaying their own ideas and demanding that people accept them without question.
You wouldn't trust a taxi-cab driver if he refused to show his license, would you? How about if you get in the car anyway, and he's swerving all over the highway and nearly gets you killed? If our everlasting life really is on the line, wouldn't we display far more caution about our belief system than about getting into a cab? I'm pretty sure we would. Or we should. Not exactly the kind of thing to be lazy about, if your entire future existence is on the line.
For JWs to expect people to take the low road and turn off their brains is an indication that they're riding with an unlicensed nutcase at the wheel. I dived out of that cab this year, and believe me, walking is a lot safer.
-sd-7