Thanks everyone for your kind words. The good thing about sites like this one is that you can make an informed decsion on what books to read 1st, 2nd, etc... (by the way, my wife just pointed out that I actually read COC and Gentile Times BEFORE my last meeting, so I stand corrected).
LittleMac asked: Just curious, what made you finally delve into the 'apostate' world?
I can't really put my finger on it, but the April 15, 2010 Watchtower with the "Overlapping Generations" was a BIG part of it. After reading that article, I knew it was time to put my fear aside and start looking behind the curtain.
Len Miller: Thanks for the compliments. The Finished Mystery was a really hard pill to swallow. I remember becoming extremely angry half through the book and I even threw it against the wall towards the end. I remember thinking: "How could Jesus have chosen the Watchtower as God's "earthly organization" in 1918 when we were peddling this 600-page book filled with deliberate lies and false predictions?"
It took a lot longer than I expected, but the shock, anger and dissapointment are all gone now.
Thanks again to everyone for all your help!