Comments You Will Not Hear at the 02-12-2012 WT Study (DECEMBER 15, 2011, pages 13-17)(GUIDED HOLY SPIRIT)
Review comments will be headed by COMMENTS
WT material from today's WT will be in black
Quotes from other sources will be indented and identified
w = Watchtower
g = Awake
jv = Proclaimers book
EXCELLENT GENERAL WEBSITE : www.jwfacts.com
Bible translations www.biblegateway.com/cgi-bin/bible
WT publications www.strictlygenteel.co.uk
WT child abuse www.silentlambs.org
Blood issue www.ajwrb.org
United Nations http://www.randytv.com/secret/unitednations.htm
Also posted on
http://exjehovahswitnessforum.yuku.com
http://www.jwsupportforum.com/index.php
http://www.jehovahswitnessrecovery.com/
WHY BE GUIDED BY
GOD’S SPIRIT?
“You are my God. Your spirit is good; may it lead me.”—PS. 143:10.
OPENING COMMENTS
The WTS says this:
*** w02 2/1 p.21 par.10***
The holy spirit does indeed play an important part in the lives of the other sheep. They symbolize their dedication to Jehovah by being baptized “in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the holy spirit.” (Matthew 28:19)
But says this is the question jws answer when they are baptized:
*** w85 6/1 p.30***
At the close of the convention baptism talk, the baptism candidates will be in position to answer with depth of understanding and heartfelt appreciation two simple questions that serve to confirm that they recognize the implications of following Christ’s example. The first question is:
On thebasisofthesacrificeofJesusChrist,haveyourepentedofyoursinsanddedicatedyourselftoJehovahtodohiswill?
The second is:
Do youunderstandthatyourdedicationandbaptismidentifyyouasoneofJehovah’sWitnessesinassociationwithGod’sspirit-directedorganization?
Having answered yes to these questions, candidates are in a right heart condition to undergo Christian baptism.
The Watchtower organization takes the place of God’s holy spirit.
START OF ARTICLE
1. Illustrate how an invisible force can guide a person.
HAVE you ever used a compass to find
your way? A compass is a simple device
with only one moving part—a magnetic
needle pointing toward the north. Because
of an invisible force known as magnetism,
the needle of the compass aligns itself with
the magnetic field surrounding the earth
between its poles. For centuries, explorers
and travelers have used the compass to
guide their way over land and sea.
COMMENTS
Why a compass? Who has or has used a compass at the KH…maybe a GPS. It takes skill and intelligence to use a compass…whereas the GPS does your thinking for you. Does a GPS have an invisible force, a signal from a satellite unseen in the sky.
2, 3. (a) What powerful force did Jehovah use
aeons ago? (b) Why should we expect God’s invisible
active force to guide our lives today?
2 There is another invisible force that is
even more essential for our guidance. What
is it? The one described in the opening verses
of the Bible. Speaking of what Jehovah accomplished
aeons ago, Genesis states: “In
the beginning God created the heavens and
the earth. “As he did so, he sent forth a powerful
force, for the creation account adds:
“God’s active force was moving to and fro.”
(Gen. 1:1, 2) What was at work? Holy spirit
—the dynamic force behind creation. We
owe our existence to Jehovah’s use of this
spirit to produce all his works.—Job 33:4; Ps.
104:30.
COMMENTS
So are jws more familiar with guidance that requires personal skill and intelligence or from the WTS publications, where your thinking is done for you?
What does Genesis 1:1,2 say in other bibles?
NIV = Spirit of God
ASV = Spirit of God (pre NWT bible used by WT)
So why the change? Is the WTS doing the thinking for jws?
3 As living, breathing humans, should we
expect God’s active force to have any further
effect on our lives? God’s own Son knew
that we should, for Jesus said to his disciples:
“The spirit . . . will guide you into all the
truth.” (John 16:13) How are we to understand
what this spirit is, and why should we
want to be guided by it?
COMMENTS
What do jws expect will happen when the spirit operates on them? How can they tell? Is the holy spirit only available and understood through the WTS? How do you know that God is blessing your through holy spirit if a) you die because of “persecution” like Steven or James or b) some survive persecution like Silas; a) some are blessed materially like Solomon and Job and b) those die in poverty? Shall jws assume that if they are well off they have God’s favor and the older sister who lives in a run down nursing home deserves it.
The Nature of Holy Spirit
4, 5. (a) What do Trinitarians wrongly think that
the holy spirit is? (b) How would you explain the
true nature of holy spirit?
4 Likely, some of the people you talk to in
the ministry believe in what the King James
Version and some other Bible translations
call the Holy Ghost. Trinitarians wrongly
think that this is a spirit person equal with
God the Father. (1 Cor. 8:6) It is noteworthy,
however, that throughout The Webster Bible,
an amended King James Version originally
published in 1833, American lexicographer
Noah Webster replaced “Holy Ghost” with
“Holy Spirit.” Webster did so because he
knew that in the Scriptures this expression
did not mean “an apparition.”*
*In the preface of his Bible, Webster wrote: “Whenever
words are understood in a sense different from that
which they had when introduced, and different from
that of the original languages, they do not present to the
reader the Word of God.”
COMMENTS
Noah Webster may have replaced “Holy Ghost” with “Holy Spirit” but the WTS has replaced it with “active force.”
So does the WTS agree with Webster’s view of the trinity?
TRIN'ITY, n. [L. trinitas; tres and unus, unitas, one, unity.]
In theology, the union of three persons in one Godhead, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.
In my whole essay, there is not any thing like an objection against the Trinity.
http://www.1828-dictionary.com/d/word/trinity
5 What, then, is the true nature of holy
spirit? A footnote at Genesis 1:2 in the
New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures—
With References states: “Besides being
translated ‘spirit,’ ru_ach [Hebrew] is also
translated ‘wind’ and by other words that
denote an invisible active force.” (Compare
footnotes at Genesis 3:8; 8:1.) Just as wind is
invisible but exerts force, so the immaterial,
impersonal holy spirit is unseen but produces
effects. This spirit is energy from God
projected and exerted on people or things to
accomplish his will. Is it hard to believe that
such a marvelous force emanates from the
holy Source, Almighty God? Not at all!
—Read Isaiah 40:12,13.
COMMENTS
Don’t confuse a footnote as being the bible itself, but rather a human explanation apart from your own.
So humans don’t have a choice if the spirit is “projected and exerted on people….his will” or other humans like the WTS? Why then are people to pray, ask for holy spirit if they cannot choose?
6. What significant appeal did David make to Jehovah?
6 Can Jehovah continue to use his spirit to
guide us through life? He promised the
psalmist David: “I shall make you have insight
and instruct you in the way you should
go.” (Ps. 32:8) Did David want that? Yes, for
he appealed to Jehovah: “Teach me to do
your will, for you are my God. Your spirit is
good; may it lead me.” (Ps. 143:10) We
should have the same desire and willingness
to be guided by God’s spirit. Why so? Consider
four reasons.
COMMENTS
David again, OT and an adulterer and murderer that somehow evaded the punishment under the Law, death.
Where was David looking for God to lead him when he saw Bathsheba, had her brought to David’s house, had sex with her, and when she became pregnant, how was David looking to God to lead him, and had Uriah murdered, even knowing that God sees all things?
We Are Not Qualified to Guide Ourselves
7, 8. (a) Why are we not able to guide ourselves independent
of God? (b) Illustrate why we dare not try
to find our own way through this wicked system of
things.
7 First, we should want to be guided by
God’s spirit because we are not capable of
guiding ourselves. “To guide” means “to direct
in a course or show the way to be followed.”
However, Jehovah did not create us
with the ability to do that for ourselves, especially
not in our imperfect condition. His
prophet Jeremiah wrote: “O Lord, I am conscious
that a man’s way is not in himself:
man has no power of guiding his steps.” (Jer.
10:23, The Bible in Basic English) And why
not? Jeremiah heard God’s analysis of why
we are impaired when it comes to directing
ourselves. Speaking of the person we are inside,
Jehovah said: “The heart is more treacherous
than anything else and is desperate.
Who can know it?”—Jer. 17:9; Matt. 15:19.
COMMENTS
David felt he could guide himself 1) adultery 2) murderer 3) census and chose death of 70,000 other people rather than himself.
The WTS excuses these sins and finds Judas worthy of eternal death but not Solomon who died an unrepentant apostate.
The WTS uses other bible translations (The Bible in Basic English); is the NWT deficient, can jws use other translations in their public talks and talks in the TMS?
http://www.gotquestions.org/Bible-Basic-English-BBE.html
8 Would it not be foolhardy for an inexperienced
person to set off alone, without a
skilled guide and not so much as a compass,
hiking deep into an uncharted wilderness?
Not knowing how to survive inhospitable
conditions in the wild and not having the
expertise to find his way safely to his destination,
he would be putting his life in jeopardy.
So, too, the person who thinks he can direct
his course through this wicked world
without allowing God to show him the right
way is placing his life in grave danger. The
only chance we have of traversing this system
of things successfully is to make the
same prayerful request to Jehovah that David
did: “Let my steps take hold on your
tracks, in which my footsteps will certainly
not be made to totter.” (Ps.17:5; 23:3) How is
it possible to receive such guidance?
COMMENTS
But would it be foolhardy to continuing using a compass that has pointed you in the wrong direction or pointed others many times>1874, 1878, 1881, 1914, 1915, 1920, 1925, 1940’s, 1975, 1984, 1994???
http://jwfacts.com/watchtower/1800s.php
Did Bible Students or later jws reach the destination of the end in 1914, 1915, 1920, 1925, 1975, 1984 (1914 + 70 years generation), 1994 (1914 + 80 years generation)?
Is it that God was wrong or that God was never leading the WTS?
9. As depicted on page 17, how can God’s spirit
serve as a sure guide for us?
9 If we are humble and willing to depend
on Jehovah, he will impart to us his holy
spirit as a sure guide for our steps. How will
that active force help us? Jesus explained to
his disciples: “The helper, the holy spirit,
which the Father will send in my name, that
one will teach you all things and bring back
to your minds all the things I told you.”
(John 14:26) As we regularly and prayerfully
study God’s Word, including all the sayings
of Christ, holy spirit will increase our comprehension
of Jehovah’s deep wisdom, so
that we can follow his will closely. (1 Cor. 2:
10) Additionally, at any unexpected turn in
the road to life, the spirit will show us the
way to go. It will bring to mind Bible principles
that we have already learned and help
us to grasp how they apply in directing our
next step.
COMMENTS
Humble enough to depend on God or was it depending on a human organization that has shown over and over it does not know where it is going?
*** w94 10/1 p.8***
All who want to understand the Bible should appreciate that the “greatly diversified wisdom of God” can become known only through Jehovah’s channel of communication, the faithful and discreet slave.—John 6:68.
It a person reads the bible and the “spirit” helps them see they are going the wrong way, can they disregard the compass direction from this human organization?
Jesus Was Guided by God’s Spirit
10, 11. What expectation did the only-begotten
Son of God have regarding holy spirit, and what did
he experience?
10 A second reason why we should want to
be guided by holy spirit is that God led his
own Son by it. Before coming to earth,
the only-begotten Son of God knew of the
prophecy: “Upon him the spirit of Jehovah
must settle down, the spirit of wisdom and
of understanding, the spirit of counsel and of
mightiness, the spirit of knowledge and of
the fear of Jehovah.” (Isa. 11:2) Just imagine
how eager Jesus was to receive the help of
God’s spirit while residing in the environment
that he faced here on earth!
COMMENTS
Did Jesus receive his direction through the religious leaders of his time or did he rebuke them when their teachings conflicted with God’s?
Or did he call them blind guides leading the blind into a ditch?
11 Jehovah’s words came true. The Gospel
record states what happened immediately after
Jesus’ baptism: “Now Jesus, full of holy
spirit, turned away from the Jordan, and he
was led about by the spirit in the wilderness.”
(Luke 4:1) There, while Jesus was fasting,
praying, and meditating, Jehovah likely instructed
and enlightened his Son about what
lay ahead for him. God’s active force was at
work on Jesus’ mind and heart, guiding his
thinking and decisions. As a result, Jesus
knew what to do in each situation, and he
did exactly what his Father wanted him
to do.
COMMENTS
LIKELY = the bible does not say, but of course the WTS info is more important than the bible.
12. Why is it necessary that we ask for God’s spirit
to lead us?
12 Knowing the value of the effects of
God’s spirit in his own life, Jesus impressed
on his disciples the importance of their asking
for and being led by holy spirit. (Read
Luke 11:9-13.) Why is that so necessary for
us? Because it can transform our thinking, so
that it resembles the mind of Christ. (Rom.
12:2; 1 Cor. 2:16) By letting God’s spirit guide
our lives, we can think as Christ does and imitate
his example.—1 Pet. 2:21.
COMMENTS
Letting god’s spirit or as explained by the WTS/FDS/GB? Bible understanding is only attained through the WTS per the WTS.
The World’s Spirit Would Lead Us Astray
13. What is the world’s spirit, and what does it produce?
13 The third reason for wanting God’s spirit
to guide us is that without it we could be
led astray by the unholy spirit that is at work
in the lives of most people today. The world
has its own powerful, impelling force that foments
a course totally opposite of what holy
spirit can produce in us. Rather than fostering
in people the mind of Christ, the world’s
spirit causes their thinking and actions to resemble
those of the ruler of the world, Satan.
(Read Ephesians 2:1-3; Titus 3:3.) When a
person gives in to the world’s spirit and takes
up practicing the works of the flesh, grave
consequences result, preventing him from
inheriting God’s Kingdom.—Gal. 5:19-21.
God’s spirit was an impelling force in Jesus’ life
COMMENTS
So MOST people (all non-jws) are led by the unholy spirit, all 7 billion, men, women, and children, even those who CLAIM to be Christians. Even having the Bible they cannot understand it without the WTS, right? Of course, no jws practice the works of the flesh, there are no pedophiles, wife beaters, children killers or wife killers, thieves, frauds, liars, etc. at the KH?!
14, 15. How can we succeed in resisting the spirit of
the world?
14 Jehovah has equipped us to resist the
spirit of the world. The apostle Paul said to
“go on acquiring power in the Lord and in
the mightiness of his strength . . . that you
may be able to resist in the wicked day.” (Eph.
6:10,13) By means of his spirit, Jehovah fortifies
us to withstand Satan’s efforts to mislead
us. (Rev. 12:9) The spirit of the world is
strong, and we cannot avoid it altogether.
However, we do not have to be corrupted by
it. Holy spirit is even stronger, and it will
help us!
COMMENTS
So you can trust your children with any adult, be assured that the handy jws won’t cheat you in business, that they won’t steal your spouse, etc.? And if they do they will be punished by the BOE? Not!
15 Of those who forsook Christianity in the
first century, the apostle Peter said: “Abandoning
the straight path, they have been
misled.” (2 Pet. 2:15) How very thankful we
can be that we have received, “not the spirit
of the world, but the spirit which is from
God”! (1 Cor. 2:12) With the help of its influence
and by taking full advantage of all of Jehovah’s
provisions to keep us on the right
path spiritually, we can succeed in resisting
the satanic spirit of this wicked world.
—Gal. 5:16.
COMMENTS
What about the brothers involved in porn, now there is a topic that pops up in every WT magazine?
Wicked world = every non-jw per the WTS and all are controlled by Satan. What about the Bethelite that was pedophile? How did Satan reach into Bethel, where was God’s spirit?
Holy Spirit Produces Good Fruitage
16. What fruitage can holy spirit produce in us?
16 A fourth reason for wanting God’s spirit
to work within us is that it produces healthy
fruitage in the lives of those who are led by
it. (Read Galatians 5:22, 23.) Who among
us would not want to be more loving, joyful,
and peaceable? Who of us would not like
to abound in long-suffering, kindness, and
goodness? Who of us would not benefit
from developing greater faith, mildness, and
self-control? God’s spirit produces in us fine
qualities that benefit us and those with
whom we live and serve. Cultivating this
fruitage is a constant work in progress, since
there is no limit to the amount of the spirit’s
fruitage that we need and are permitted to
produce.
COMMENTS
Healthy fruitage: hypocrites that cheat, lie, back stab, pretend to be good when they are not, lack mercy, kind only to their “friends,” label or mark others as bad association and then wonder why they feel unloved and don’t feel welcome at the KH, who haven’t made a return visit in years because they don’t want to be tied down to a bible study evenings or weekends…..the jws who haven’t talked to each other for years, sat near each other at the KH, refuse to be a householder for that jw, never invite them to their annual picnic; and not content with than gossip to any new jw to the congregation that they should also avoid that family?
17. How can we cultivate an aspect of the fruitage of
the spirit to a greater extent?
17 We are wise to take stock of ourselves to
be sure that our words and actions give evidence
that we are directed by holy spirit and
are producing its fruitage. (2 Cor. 13:5a; Gal.
5:25) If we see that we need to cultivate
some aspects of the fruitage of the spirit, we
can cooperate with holy spirit to a greater
degree in producing such qualities. We do
this by studying each aspect as it is revealed
through the pages of the Bible and discussed
in our Christian publications. Thus we can
discern how the spirit’s fruitage should be
manifested in our everyday life and then
work to cultivate it to a greater extent.* As we
observe the results of the operation of God’s
spirit in our own life as well as in the lives of
our fellow Christians, we clearly see why we
must be guided by it.
*For a discussion of each aspect, see the subject
“Fruitage of God’s Spirit” and the heading “List by Aspect”
in the Watch Tower Publications Indexes.
COMMENTS
Take stock of ourselves = don’t bother, the elders and other “mature” ones will take a more “accurate” stock of you.
How many jws can name the 9 fruits of the spirit without looking? How many elders can name the teams, coaches, and QBs of every NFL team though?
Fellow Christians = only jws; but if you ask a jw what religion they are they will almost always say = jw but not “I’m a Christian” someone might think they are a Baptist.
Are You Yielding to God’s Spirit?
18. How is Jesus a model for us in responding to
God’s spirit?
18 As God’s “master worker” in the creation
of the physical universe, Jesus knew all
about the earth’s magnetic field, which humans
use to navigate the earth. (Prov. 8:30;
John 1:3) However, there is no evidence in
the Bible that Jesus ever used that force to
guide his way when he was on earth. The Bible
does report that as a human, he experienced what
a powerful force God’s holy spirit
was in his life. He welcomed its influence,
and when it impelled him, he yielded and
acted accordingly. (Mark 1:12, 13; Luke 4:14)
Are you of that sort?
COMMENTS
Jesus knew about the magnetic field = but never said anything about it
NO Evidence in the Bible that he used that force = why bring it up then?
Remember that Jesus did not use the guidance of the religious leaders of his day but went straight to the bible and his father’s direction.
(Matthew 15:12-14) . . .Then the disciples came up and said to him: “Do you know that the Pharisees stumbled at hearing what you said?” In reply he said: “Every plant that my heavenly Father did not plant will be uprooted. LET them be. Blind guides is what they are. If, then, a blind man guides a blind man, both will fall into a pit.”
19. What must we do for holy spirit to become the
guiding force in our life?
19 God’s active force still operates on willing
minds and hearts to move and guide
them. How can you let it work upon you to
lead you in the right direction? Pray constantly
to Jehovah that he send you his spirit
and help you yield to its influence. (Read
Ephesians 3:14-16.)Work in harmony with
your prayers by searching out the counsel
found in God’s written Word, the Bible—a
product of holy spirit. (2 Tim. 3:16, 17) Obey
the wise instructions it offers, and then respond
eagerly to the leading of holy spirit.
Act with faith in Jehovah’s ability to guide
you properly through life in this wicked
world.
COMMENTS
Willing minds and hearts = only jws, the rest are under Satan’s influence per the WTS
And what if the spirit tells you the WTS is leading you in the wrong direction? 1874, 1878, 1881, 1914, 1915, 1925, 1975, 1984, 1994
WTS are not “products of holy spirit” but imperfect humans.
God’s spirit operates on minds and hearts to move and guide them
Did You Get the Main Points?
How can holy spirit affect our lives?
What are four reasons why we
should want to be guided by
God’s spirit?
How can we do our part to benefit
fully from the leading of holy
spirit?
CLOSING COMMENTS
Next week, FAITHFUL ONES OF OLD—GUIDED BY GOD’S SPIRIT. Once again the WTS is reduced to OT not NT examples. Were there no faithful Christians?
Love, Blondie