I found another thread there that is interesting...
From: Joel (Original Message) Sent: 07/03/2001 23:27
This morning I recieved an email from a new member, *tc*, informing me of an apostate lurking within us.
Well I didn't like that very much! Immediately I banned that individual, his name was Asher.
Now that I've had time to think about it though, I feel pretty bad that I didn't at least give Asher the chance to defend himself. Did I make a mistake?
It's not as if this community is used very much, I certainly don't remeber any posts from Asher at all!
If anyone reading this thinks they could help me in managing and stimulating this group then please speak up.
I'd like to appoint one or two assistant managers.
Well that's it for now, speak to you all again soon.
Warm brotherly love,
Joel
P.S
Enjoy your trip to America Tone'!
First Previous 2-15 of 15 Next Last
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 2 of 15 in Discussion
From: ¤tc¤ Sent: 08/03/2001 09:49
Joel,
I appreciate your expediency, and understand your seconds thoughts as well, being a manager of another community. However, your actions were warranted by Scripture (2 John 9-11), and if you have reservations about the authenticity of my claims, they can be substantiated by others who know who asher is. I suppose (and sincerely hope) that you are not a member of the alt.JW community, but if you are or any other members here are, they can tell you that the person who posts under the name 'nicholau' (asher) is nothing but opposed to the Truth. He even has gone as far as to make available the confidential publication used by the body of elders to assist them in carrying out their responsibilty as shepherds. That is most inappropriate and reprehensible action. He posts material from the JW-hate sites, and encourages all to have "heated debates". It is not a community for any who want to remain clean in Jehovah's sight, and that should be a concern for us all.
Asher can make a good "show" for himself, and is very "smooth" about his deception. But he is, without a doubt, unfit association. The fact that he is silent here gives rise to the question of why he was removed, but rest assured, the material he reads here is used elsewhere, but twisted and used to further his own ends, to damage the faith of any who may be spiritually young and weak among the community's members.
I recommend that others who can verify asher's true identity post here to reassure Joel that he did the correct thing. I would not chose to remain here at this community along with known apostates, so if he were not removed, I would be bound to follow scriptural counsel and take leave myself. I would rather stay among my brothers and sisters however, and make more aquaintances among the cyber-world congregation.
Again, thank you for taking appropriate action, Joel.
Sincerely, and with warm Christian love,
tc
ps: if u feel the need to remove this post after reading it, please do so, it will cause no offense. This was merely the most convenient way to respond at the moment.
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 3 of 15 in Discussion
From: Ryck Sent: 31/03/2001 12:58
Well, other people like to jump the gun on a rumor. I tend to be more patient and collect the facts. I question the source and I question the target of the rumor. Sometimes I even bring the accuser and the accused together. Often it was either something was taken out of context, a mistake, a misunderstanding, or a lie. I don't like this going behind peoples' back kind of thing; not in judgement nor in practice. I wouldn't want the same done to me.
If I were to base my outlook of Jehovah's Witnesses on what I heard of Jehovah's Witnesses, I wouldn't be one today. I'm glad I looked into Jehovah's Witnesses for myself.
That's my $0.02.
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 4 of 15 in Discussion
From: Gathlon Sent: 04/04/2001 08:44
Hi everyone!
I'm new here and just started checking the message board. I read about Asher. When Asher is the same person as nicolaou, then I'm certain he's no good. You would only have to check www.jehovahs-witness.com and read some of the postings from nicolaou, but I don't recommend going there!! Since march 15 I have a JW page online. JWL, Jehovah's Witnesses Linkpage. http://jwl.mainpage.net . It's pure friendly and I will do my best to keep it clean, just like Joel does everything to keep this community clean. I mention my JWsite because nicolaou posted a message on that j-w.com site which was everything but positive. I found that out because in the NedStat statistics on the site I could see where some visitors came from. I went there to see where they came from. It was the j-w.com forum. "Ultimate JW Butt-Kissing Site" he called his message. That makes clear that it's a friendly one, lol, but a little exaggerated to put it that way. I copied this line from the forum and pasted it right in here:
Ultimate JW Butt-Kissing Site! nicolaou 2 <NOBR>Mar 21, 2001</NOBR> <NOBR>5:31:02 PM</NOBR>
I just saw that there is a new reply on it. I just checked a few postings from nicolaou and he's very smooth. He tells bad news, doubts, negative news articles, but does not really give his own opinion on it. He leads others to think bad of JW, and conclude wrong things about JW, gives others a bad idea of JW. All he gets are apostate replies. Those replies are not to speak against him or to dispute his posts but they only strengthen the negative intention. No positive word is found.
So, when Asher seems to be nicolaou then Joel did good! Keep up the good work!
And visit my butt-kissing site! http://jwl.mainpage.net ;o) New layout since today!!
Rotjong.
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 5 of 15 in Discussion
From: The Michael Sent: 13/04/2001 18:38
It is very sad that Jehovah's Witnesses are so easily duped into going along with some sites. The membership of Alt Jehovah's witnesses (now closed and records kept by msn for legal reasons but reopened at Anointed etc.) was quite extensive. One wonders at how many of them are sad anoraks. Probably many had assumed multiple identities. Who knows perhaps one in there will become a convert to truth and expose there ways. Perhaps a brother or investigator in MS communities will blow the whistle.
I believe most brothers will have soon left that community and been put off joining others. No weapon formed against Jehovah's people will have effect though and diamonds are sharpened by diamond.
It will be interesting to watch the outcome of these sites as their contributors dig in deep trouble for themselves.
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 6 of 15 in Discussion
From: Jenlynn Sent: 16/04/2001 13:44
Dear Joel,
If it eases your mind, you did the right thing. I went to a JW chat room once and had some lovely conversations with several people. Then I decided to go idle to see what was happening. After being idle for a little time, I discovered that the others I had been talking to were indeed apostates, they were actually laughing and saying things like all JW's were brain damaged! In the meantime, new ones appeared online and I would warn them in private, but no one would listen, so I left, never to return. It was indeed scary, because these same people were so nice when they talked to me before I went idle. It is easy to be fooled by their slick ways of deceit. I sure was! But, I learned my lesson to only be more wary of anyone I do not know personally online. In your investigations of these ones, I hope you give prayerful thought to the hard job of determining just who is or is not apostate. But, if they truly are not apostates, they will let you know, I feel sure, by their actions and words posted. So, rest assured that you were probably right in doing what you did. Better to err on the side of caution, then to cause one to stumble.
Jenlynn
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 7 of 15 in Discussion
From: Ryck Sent: 20/04/2001 19:53
Nice links, Gathon!
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 8 of 15 in Discussion
From: Gathlon Sent: 22/04/2001 05:41
Yeah nice links, thanks, and I have more. Just didn't get to putting them in the list.
Could some of you let me know what you think of JWL? I am thinking about a new design again. Or greatly improving the one we have now.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Important message: USE JWL!!!!!!!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Greetz,
Gathlon
http://jwl.mainpage.net
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 9 of 15 in Discussion
From: FrailMermaid Sent: 11/05/2001 18:24
I'm glad you are paying attention to any possible apostates. I would love to have ONE place to be able to go to without being bothered by apostates. Everytime I have tried a JW chat room, there is always someone wanting to debate or the conversation is definitely not christian or upbuilding. I'm glad you kicked this person off.
Your sister in the faith!
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 10 of 15 in Discussion
From: John Sent: 25/06/2001 02:15
How do you know you kicked of the right person if he has never posted? I remember doing a talk last year about Justice. The effect was Jehovah would rather let the guilty go free than punish the innocent. You should be ashamed. Asher is a common name in many places. I don't understand your basis for such a decision. Shouldn't you have two or three witnesses?
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 11 of 15 in Discussion
From: Joel Sent: 27/06/2001 04:46
"Jehovah would rather let the guilty go free than punish the innocent. You should be ashamed. Asher is a common name in many places"
Strong words John!
In fact Nicolaou himself confirmed his pseudo identity as Asher in another MSN community, 'Jehovah's Christian Witnesses'.
*tc* should be able to verify this.
I'd like to advise everyone not to get too paranoid about associations in here. I may not post very much but I certainly do monitor and I certainly will not tolerate apostate or insulting material.
Please try to enjoy yourselves and remember that this is a place for encouragement and upbuilding association.
Your brother
Joel
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 12 of 15 in Discussion
From: michael Sent: 28/06/2001 05:13
John,
I know for a fact that you have been communicating with Nicolaou via his apostate do-not-call.org site and are a member of his alt.community as well!
You are a hypocrite!
michael
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 13 of 15 in Discussion
From: Letstalk Sent: 29/06/2001 02:35
Joel,
I dont understand why you are feeling bad about banning a known apostate from this community. What does Jehovah God do with apostates that arise within the congregation. Apostates have chosen not only to stop serving Jehovah, BUT also to corrupt the faith of others.
Why is it ok to associate with them on the internet community and not within the brotherhood? As for those who think Joel should be ashamed, maybe a little look at a Kingdom Ministry article from about 2 yrs ago is needed!!
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 14 of 15 in Discussion
From: Joel Sent: 29/06/2001 09:00
Letstalk
when I made my original post back in March I was unsure whether Asher was indeed an apostate or not. It was this uncertainty and the haste with which I acted that troubled me. As I said back then "I didn't at least give Asher the chance to defend himself."
Now that all seems pretty academic. It appears that Asher and Nicolaou are indeed one and the same and so I feel I acted correctly (though if there is ever a 'next time' I will at least let anyone accused of apostay make a defence.)
Hope that settles it for everyone.
Joel
Reply
Recommend (0 recommendations so far) Message 15 of 15 in Discussion
From: elelou44 Sent: 06/07/2001 14:30
Hi joel
Iv'e only just joined this community 2nite and was looking through the messages when i saw yours i had to reply, no i don't think you made a mistake , the reason being , we are warned about going in to the internet chat rooms for that very reason ,that there might be apostates lurking and that could seriously damage our faith ,satan can be very cunning in his methods , i joined to se if my friend was still on the net ,ice 765?? . Its hard to find genuine sites where you can have chats to genuine brothers and sisters isn't it .I hope to meet /chat to some of you dear brothers and sisters soon by the way i went to plymouth assembly to as did Ian
warm christian love elelou