Not Breaking News: Jehovah’s Witness Won in Court Over Medicaid Coverage

by Scott77 11 Replies latest social current

  • Scott77
    Scott77

    Sorry, old news but is typical Watchtower Society of

    Jehovah’s Witnesses as they face life and death events. I think, they want to die as martyrs. Sigh.

    Scott77

    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Jehovah’s Witness qualifies for coverage, but too late for transplant

    By BRAD COOPER
    The Kansas City Star

    Mary Stinemetz beat the state in a precedent-setting religious freedom case, but she’s losing the battle against a chronic liver disease.

    Stinemetz is terminally ill after she was unable to get a liver transplant even though she won a legal battle that forced the state to honor her faith and pay for an out-of-state liver transplant.

    No one can say for sure how much time she has left.

    “Anything can happen at any minute,” Stinemetz’s husband, Merlyn, said Tuesday. “Her condition deteriorates regardless of what you do. You can’t stop it.”

    A Jehovah’s Witness from the western Kansas town of Hill City, Stinemetz got a Kansas appeals court to find that the state violated her constitutional right to exercise her religious faith when it denied Medicaid coverage for an out-of-state liver transplant.

    Stinemetz, 65, refused to undergo a liver transplant at the University of Kansas Hospital because she would need a blood transfusion — something she couldn’t accept as a Jehovah’s Witness. She wanted to receive a special bloodless transplant in Nebraska instead.

    The state agreed to cover the procedure but by the time she could get on a transplant list, her condition had worsened to a point where she was no longer eligible for a new liver.

    “The only thing I had going for me was the liver transplant and that’s out of the picture.” Stinemetz said. “There’s just no cure for it. I’m going to get progressively worse.”

    Maybe if the state had more readily agreed to fund the transplant instead of battling the case in court, she said, the outcome would be different.

    “To be honest with you, they dragged their feet too long,” she said. “That’s OK, because it sets precedent for others who are Jehovah’s people so they won’t have the problems I had.”

    State officials had argued in court that there was no medical necessity for a bloodless transplant, and that her religious preference shouldn’t determine insurance coverage.

    For 20 years, Stinemetz has suffered from primary biliary cirrhosis, a chronic disease that causes the liver to deteriorate and malfunction over time.

    Even now, it’s not easy getting treatment locally because there are few physicians willing to treat her condition without the ability to give her a blood transfusion.

    Merlyn Stinemetz said he even has trouble getting his wife admitted to local hospitals so she can have fluid drained from her lungs and abdomen.

    The Stinemetzes are planning to go to Denver where they can be closer to their daughter and to doctors who are willing to treat her condition without blood transfusions.

    “We wouldn’t be traveling all these miles,” he said, “if we had doctors that would conform to your worship wishes.”

    Stinemetz said she has no idea how much time she has left. But she’s more focused on eternity than the here and now.

    “I am just thankful I have the hope of the Resurrection. That means a lot to me,” she said. “I look forward to the Resurrection if I do die.”

    To reach Brad Cooper, call 816-234-7724 or send email to [email protected].

    Posted on Tue, Jul. 24, 2012 09:19 PM

    Read more here: http://www.kansascity.com/2012/07/24/3721699/jehovahs-witness-qualifies-for.html#storylink=cpy

  • The Oracle
    The Oracle

    Poor misguided fool. *sigh*

    How many more lives will the WT literally ruin before the majority of members stand up and say - ENOUGH.?

    I hope not many.

  • Scott77
    Scott77

    “I am just thankful I have the hope of the Resurrection. That means a lot to me,...I look forward to the Resurrection if I do die.”
    Stinemetz

    The Oracle,

    I agree with you. "They are Poor misguided fool". That is so sickening and foolish to say the least. Does not Stinemetz know that the Watchtower society of Jehovah's Witnesses now allow blood transfusion parts that were previously banned? Even more troubling, the bible only speaks about animal blood not human blood. The two are not the same.

    Scott77

  • diamondiiz
    diamondiiz

    I wonder if she dies will they sue the state? Glad that she's got a hope of resurrection because it's better to be delusional about that than realizing she's been conned to give up her life for a fucking cult and have no future life here nor resurrection.

  • loosie
    loosie

    I spoke with a doctor that I work with. There is no way to do a liver transplant without some of the donors blood coming along with the liver into the recipient. So the whole idea of transfusion is silly because she will have foreign blood in her anyway.

  • nugget
    nugget

    If she had this condition for so long why didn't she move sooner to a place where she could have a better chance of bloodless surgery. It frustrates me that these people hold an extreme view and then do not help themselves. The faith teaches indolence not pro activity with the thought that things will be better at some point in the future. Life is so precious and our time so brief it should not be squandered.

  • Scott77
  • Scott77
    Scott77

    I wonder if she dies will they sue the state? Glad that she's got a hope of resurrection because it's better to be delusional about that than realizing she's been conned to give up her life for a fucking cult and have no future life here nor resurrection.
    diamondiiz

    I thought that was a powerful question to ask,"I wonder if she dies will they sue the state?". I would not be surprised if the Watchtower Attorneys greedy as they are, would not incite that misguided patient to sue the state. You never know what is in their mind.

    Scott77

  • DesirousOfChange
    DesirousOfChange

    It will be a well attended Memorial Service.

    Standing room only at the Kingdom Hall.

    Her family will be proud.

    Doc

  • Scott77
    Scott77

    It will be a well attended Memorial Service.Standing room only at the Kingdom Hall.Her family will be proud.

    DesirousOfChange

    Unfortunately, I have no idea if Stinemetz is still fighting for his life or no more of that. However, I agree with you. It could turn out to be a cause for cerebration. Silly,they glority death in the name of a cult. I think, that is horrific and terrible at that.

    Scott77

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit