Hello again NickL.
So much debate and confusion could be avoided by concerning ourselves with the "printed" comments of the WBTS and not judging the organization by the actions and words of some associated with it.
Why would we concern ourselves with printed materials that will be revised next year? No doubt the "printed" material by which we discussed things now would be taboo in a few years, especially if the society was blessed with "new light" on the subject.
Please remember that a catholic believes he is right because the POPE (mouthpiece of God) says so. You believe he is WRONG because your governing body (mouthpiece of God) says so. It is a matter of opinion. We are here to discuss differences in OUR opinion, not of a number of men who feel themselves annoited by God.
Jehovah God gave you free will, and you are free to use it on this board.