"is crowded with religious figurines, most of which came from the local Catholic Store."
It really depends on whether or not your local elders like you. If they do.....they may just give you counsel that it could stumble others and leave it at that. If they don't, they could say that you are supposed to quit touching the unclean thing. You are voluntarily rubbing elbows with babylon the great........and you are being "brazen" about it. Prepare for a judicial committee for "brazen conduct".
The possibilities are endless.