Punctuation within and without quotation marks

by compound complex 73 Replies latest social physical

  • compound complex
    compound complex

    Despite sharing a common English language, U.S. and British punctuation rules differ in ways we may not often realize. The British style has become more acceptable in the U.S. since many consider it more logical, but academic and professional writing in the U.S. still demands using the U.S. style. Having said that, a publisher’s style (often found in a style manual) may take precedence over a culture’s accepted rules. Consult your style manual for its requirements.

    Quotation Marks

    In the U.S. style, we use double quotation marks to indicate a direct quote and single quotation marks to set off a quote within a quote.

    Ex. Brian’s dad always says, “Boys will be boys.” or Brian laughingly stated, “My dad always says, ‘Boys will be boys.’”

    In the British style, the marks are often reversed, using single marks for primary quotes and double marks for quotes within quotes.

    Ex. The sign read, ‘Please queue against the right wall only’. or ‘The woman just said, “Please queue against the right wall only”’, Hermione explained.

    Periods and Commas

    In the U.S. style, periods and commas come within closing quotation marks.

    Ex. Taylor begged weakly, “Please don’t ground me; it’s the weekend.”

    In the British style, periods and commas come outside closing quotation marks.

    Ex. ‘The first step on the journey to success is to pick up one’s foot and move it’, my wisecrack teacher stated philosophically.

    Ex. The constable ordered the biker, ‘Stay out of the bus lane, sir’.

    http://www.uhv.edu/ac/newsletters/writing/grammartip2007.09.04.htm

  • Jeffro
    Jeffro

    I'm sure we punctuated outside the close of quotation marks years ago.

    Style guides do vary regarding the use of punctuation inside or outside of quotation marks, even in the UK (and here, in Australia). More often, though, it seems that careful editors here do prefer the 'correct' punctuation. This style is attested at least as far back as the 1920s.

  • Jeffro
    Jeffro

    Punctuation within and without quotation marks

    "Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend. Inside of a dog, it's too dark to read." — Groucho Marx.

  • Bobcat
    Bobcat

    KurtBethel:

    One more question about quotation marks:

    Clickable link opens a new tab so you do not leave this site.

    How do you accomplish this? Is there an ASCII code sequence you insert?

  • Jeffro
    Jeffro

    Bobcat:

    Clickable link opens a new tab so you do not leave this site.How do you accomplish this? Is there an ASCII code sequence you insert?

    Include a target parameter in the HTML tag for the link. If you insert a link using the forum's toolbar, there is a Target dropdown providing various options.

  • Bobcat
    Bobcat

    Jeffro:

    In keeping with the thread, "thanks." (or, perhaps you prefer "thank$.")

  • compound complex
    compound complex

    Hey, Bob !

    Thanks!

    BTTT for LV101

  • Band on the Run
    Band on the Run

    I take writing courses frequently. Being consistent within a document is a good rule of thumb. I am shocked at the divergence of rules in Britain and the U.S. Now I am curious about other British colonies. We were told never to start a sentence with "however," because of some rule in French grammar. French was the universal language for the middle class and above throughout Europe. Also, people make a big deal about never splitting an infinitive. I would work so hard to rewrite a sentence. The result was often tortured. Some professional editors told me the rule was ridiculous.

    Editors use English in normal life. Academics tend to collect it. Language evolves.

  • compound complex
    compound complex

    We were told never to start a sentence with [...]

    Excellent example, Band, of NOT splitting an infinitive!

    You're correct: the results are sometimes tortured when being more strict than reasonable, whether with both the refusal to split an infinitive or to end a sentence with a preposition:

    'There are some things up with which I will not put.'

    Thanks!

    CC

  • compound complex
    compound complex

    More than a few people would say it is inelegant to begin a sentence in English with a conjunction. "However" can serve as a conjunction, and that is probably what your professor has in mind. There is, however, another use of "however", and that is as an adverb. There is no objection to beginning a sentence with an adverb, and so there would be no problem with saying, for example, "However carefully I try to eat spaghetti, I always get tomato sauce on my shirt."

    http://forum.wordreference.com/showthread.php?t=1377663

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit