It seems that many former Jw's go through this. I did. I still am finding my way almost 10 years into my exit.
I find that on most issues I am moderate. I think both parties take strong stands that are unbalanced in some ways. There are moderate positions on almost all issues that are not all or nothing. I embrace fewer conservative issues than liberal ones now - but like you, my initial voting and leaning were toward Republicans. I don't fit cleanly into any of the main parties - but my absolute opposition to gods and magical thinking takes most of the Republican ideologies out of the game for me. If there was a god, I would be thanking him profusely that Mitt and the magic underwear cabinet did not win this election. I support gay rights, the need for population control and birth control, alternative energy. I also believe in the 2nd amendment and gun ownership - though I think it needs to be addressed nationally.
Isn't it great to be able to think and express those thoughts. I believe that in some ways former cult members make better citizens because to us it was not always allowed. We tend to think it through instead of just voting absentmindedly like millions do who never had the right usurped by the GB.
Jeff