The Society recommended a book written by a demon-inspired woman

by The Quiet One 25 Replies latest watchtower scandals

  • Sapphy
    Sapphy

    It's easily downloadable from here http://archive.org/details/seolaxxx00smitiala

    It's not a bad read if you like lady-like literature from the late 19th century, as I do.

    There's not a lot of laughs in it though!

  • Mellow
    Mellow

    Wow WTF!!!

  • AlphaMan
    AlphaMan

    Wasn't the Watchtower leadership's line of reasoning......truth, even if it is from a demon is truth?

  • bats in the belfry
    bats in the belfry

    .

    From The Golden Age magazine:

    February 25, 1925, page 349

  • Acluetofindtheuser
    Acluetofindtheuser

    Comparing the foreword of “Angels and Women (1924)” to the Appendix of “Seola (1878)”, mainly the sections invoking this conspiracy.

    Angels and Women – foreword

    “The reviser of this book is of the opinion that the original manuscript was dictated to the woman who wrote it by one of the fallen angels who desired to return to divine favor.”

    Seola – appendix

    “Seola is a fantasy, revealed to the writer while listening to the performance of an extraordinary musical composition. It was sudden and unforeseen as the landscape which sometimes appears to a benighted traveler, for one instant only, illumined by the lightning’s flash.

    It does not therefore pretend to be either history or theology, but yet the theory upon which the story is founded is in strict accordance with the sacred writings of the Hebrews and traditions of other ancient nations. It may be briefly stated.

    In the early ages of the world angelic beings became incarnate, assumed the likeness of men, left the service of God, visited the earth, mingled in its affairs, formed the most intimate connection with women and became the fathers of a progeny physically magnificent and spiritually corrupt. These powerful and depraved beings subverted the government of the earth and filled it with intolerable crimes. The Almighty put an end to this unnatural condition by sending a great deluge to destroy the kingdom of the Devas with their giant offspring and by imprisoning them in chains and darkness the angels who had been guilty of the offence, though certain evil spirits are still permitted to roam the earth.

    This theory, set forth in a work entitled “From Dawn to Sunrise,” having been the subject of much comment, it may be proper to recapitulate the evidence of its truth in this place.”

    The reviser of Angels and Women was in error about it being an automatic writing. The appendix section of Seola clearly states that this was the work of the imagination, with a great deal of research as its source. Maybe if they left out the foreword section of Angels and Women there wouldn’t be this kind of accusation. The society today should just apologize about the foreword and mention it again in the Awake! Magazine and see what the publishers think. That would be a doozy. In my opinion the story is great but it’s not for everyone.

  • Violia
    Violia

    I own this and it is not a half bad read.

  • dropoffyourkeylee
    dropoffyourkeylee

    I have a copy of this as well as another of her novels. When my mother studied in the early sixties this book was still passed around as good reading. The supposed spirit connection is entirely the result of the forward to 'angels and women'. Mrs. Smith did not write the forward, in fact she had died years before and was never aware that her 'Seola' was republished. in my opinion her books are simply fanciful nineteenth century fiction... Nothing more. no more spirit influenced than Star Trek ,Star Wars , star gate, or any science fiction.

    The question remains as to who wrote that forward? My vote is for Clayton Woodworth, who of all the early Bible Students was probably the goofiest.

  • truthseeker
  • EndofMysteries
    EndofMysteries

    "Angels and Women" was the rewrite to make it go a little more with Rutherford (since can't verify about Russel) teachings. The original book was called "Seola".

    I like the title of your thread, I think I made the exact same thread title a few years ago lol. I'm gonna check real quick...

  • EndofMysteries

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit