Sunday movie, "Living with the Dead"

by Mulan 23 Replies latest jw friends

  • circe2
    circe2

    I enjoyed the movie the same way I enjoyed Sixth Sense.

    However I believe Van Praagh is as much as a fraud as Edwards. He does employ "cold reading" (just like Edwards does).

    Here is a link that discusses his "technique": http://www.csicop.org/articles/19990608-vanpraagh/index.html

    I found it amusing that many of the commercials during the movie were to push his new daytime psychic talk show that will be airing soon.

    I'm a very spiritual person, but I'm also a skeptic. (The two traits can co-exist. ) I believe there is more to reality than what we see, but I don't think that people like Van Praagh acurately represent that unseen reality. I think they do what they do for power and profit. It makes me sad.

    circe

  • Sargon
    Sargon

    I enjoyed it but it didn't come anywhere near the 6th Sense.


    Imagination is more important than Knowledge. Albert Einstein

  • Mulan
    Mulan

    I watched him on Larry King the other night, and he was "right on", and did not do cold readings. He told a woman her brother, Mike, was sending her a message, and the things he said were true. He is in a Navy uniform, holding a necklace, etc. Larry emphasized that he had no way of knowing the calls coming in ahead of time, etc. That is just one example.

    John Edward would say, "I have a man, with a name that starts with M" then list several M names, "was he in the military?" etc. Not a hard thing to guess, if it's an older woman, whose family would have likely served in WW2. That is what I call cold reading.........I've never seen James VP do it that way..........or Sylvia Brown. They are specific.

    As to why the dead would talk to them?..........who knows? I am just fascinated by this, and open to the possibility. Why not?

    I read the link to the Larry King show in 1999, which I didn't see. All I can say is the one last week, was incredible.

    I also saw Mary Steenburgen on The View last week, promoting this movie, and she said some friends of hers dropped by the set, and James asked them which one of them had an uncle with a glass eye, because he was sending a message. They were all floored. She said she was skeptical until that happened. It was friends that she hadn't seen for awhile, and he would have no way of knowing they were coming to the set.

    Marilyn (aka Mulan)
    "No one can take advantage of you, without your permission." Ann Landers

  • Princess
    Princess

    That's amazing mom. I totally believe that, and I had no idea Scott saw her too. The kids just talk about her all the time, I hope she knows, especially since Z has taken to the blanket she made her.

    Ask B.B. if she has had any experiences relating to Sharon. You know who I mean don't you? Our friend who has many experiences with the paranormal.

    Rachel

  • Mulan
    Mulan

    I'll ask her. If anyone else has had this kind of experience, it would be her. Maybe Z now because of the blanket. Ask her if she ever remembers her dreams, and if she dreams about Sharon.

    Marilyn (aka Mulan)
    "No one can take advantage of you, without your permission." Ann Landers

  • Tinkerbell4125
    Tinkerbell4125

    I've often wondered about dreams, the meaning of dreams, if the dead can come to you in dreams. I know it sounds wierd. I lost my dad to suicide and I took it pretty hard. I was angry more than anything, but anyway, one night I had the wildest dream. I dreamed that he and I were sitting together crying. *He never cryed a day in his life.* We were holding hands. *I don't think he ever held my hand.* He looked at me and told me how sorry he was. *He never told me he was sorry for anything in his life.* In the dream, he said that if he had known how it would have effected me, he would have never done it. I wondered later if it was him or maybe a angel comforting me or something, I donno......
    But anyway, it made me wonder! Tink =;o)

  • lydia
    lydia

    Marilyn,
    I watched the Movie and was intrigued as you have been - I have know of several who had contact with those who have passed on - My Grandmother sat up when she was dying and told my GrandFather ( who had been gone for several years) she would go with him the next day - and she did - she died the next morning.

    I also had an experience once where an old friend fromschool showed up in a dream one time and calmed me down durring a hard time in my life - I was so releived and calm after talking to him.. when I woke up I finally remembered he had been dead for 13 years! BUt I felt his presence as if he was beside me.

    I have no doupt this can happen - nd I look forward to the conculsion of this tonight.

    Lyd

  • Tinkerbell4125
    Tinkerbell4125

    I'm gonna watch it tonight. I didn't watch it Sunday. We always watch The Saprano's and Six Feet Under on Sunday nights.
    I really liked The Sixth Sense, so I'm looking forward to watching tonight! Tink =;o)

  • Mulan
    Mulan

    Tinkerbell, I would have to believe it was your Dad giving you a message. That is a great dream...........so comforting.

    My husband has said, since we watched the movie "if this is true, then the dead aren't dead, like we always believed. so........where are they?" Sylvia Brown says they are here, in another dimension. That makes sense to me. It kind of takes the fear of death, someday, if we can still see everyone. I just wish we could see them. Maybe the spirit realm is here........in another dimension.

    Marilyn (aka Mulan)
    "No one can take advantage of you, without your permission." Ann Landers

  • QCA1
    QCA1

    Hi Mulan

    I have been studying this subject now for 20yrs and i believe in my heart there is life after death,i have experienced several things having sat in a circle with very gifted mediums,if this is the so called devils work then more power to his elbow.I would like to tell you about a sitting i had a few years ago with a medium.I had been searching for my dads mum over a period of time,as he never knew her,i got my dads birth certificate and found his mothers name on it,anyway during this time i didn't know she had died when i went to the medium.During the sitting i asked who was speaking to him and he said Mary she is your Grandmother and Mulan what she knew about me was incredible,she named all my children my 2 husbands and so on,but here is the best bit,she told the medium that she had another son,so me being me i decided to go to London to the Births Marriages and deaths agency and look through the records and i found him my dads half brother he was born in 1934 to Mary Winifred McCarthy,now to me that is first class evidence of life after death because no one knows this least of all my dad,so someone was communicating with the medium.
    Yes there is lots to know on this subject and it can be a very exciting path to follow but unfortunetly it dosen't suit everyone there are pitfalls.For me life has made more sense than it ever has it has given me answers that appeal to my reasoning more than any orthodox religion could ever do,i could go on and on but i won't,it is an interesting subject and there are lots of books on this to.
    Thanks for posting this it has generated a lot of interest.

    qca1

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit