This problem may be geographical. No one discusses religion much in New York. It isn't worth the stress. There is so much diversity what would it accomplish. When I moved to a Bible belt in PA, almost everyone does. Mainstream religions, such as Lutherans, Anglicans, Presbyterians, Methodists, etc. dont' press the issue. Pentecostals and Baptists, along with smaller fundamentalist denominations, are constantly trolling for conversations. They assume that they can convince you. These people know few facts or even scripture. It is mostly a feeling thing. The local culture encourages this feelings aspect.
In PA, members of one group would actually interrupt people grocery shopping or doing laundry and ask, seemingly so interested, "What religion are you?" I fell for it. When I said, "Episcopal and signaled annoyance at the privacy intrusion," the person responded, "Well, I belong to the Christian church." I responded "Bully for you. I hope you are happy." Soon I was hearing the same story from my sister and other church members. So far they have converted no one and many are hoping for a chance to even the score.
I used a nice laundromat, run by a Mennonite. He dumped all the Avons and classifieds so we could only read Mennonite tracts. I sent him a note that I would now bring my own reading material. Further, if anyone opens a laundromat within the area and has regular magazines, I will take my business elsewhere.
Fundamentalists have poor boundaries. I never lived in such an area in my life. The experience was not pleasant. It is one of the reasons I left. Cultures change in America.