I enjoyed the letter. It was well written. Thanks for sharing it.
What's mind-boggling is that the person being disfellowshipped is so much more honest, truthful, and a person of integrity than the elders on the committee. You have to swallow your honest expression and conscience to be a JW - assuming you have a brain.
I wonder how many elders disfellowship persons like yourself while knowing full-well you are the one in the right. I personally think it is more than you might imagine. There are a lot of brothers serving for selfish reasons. Many do not know if it's the truth nor do they care. They are getting what they want out of the deal.
If there is a God and a Judgement Day, there will be a lot of dead Jehovah's Witnesses.
-TE