Neon Madman suggested that Bill Bowen and Barbara Anderson were instuments of Jehovah similar to Jeremiah. I merely replied that if that were true it would mean that Jehovah's Witnesses were in fact God's people after all, since the reason that Jehovah sent Jeremiah to the Jews was to get them to live up to their covenant with him. Obviously, Madman hadn't really thought that all they way through. / You Know
Actually, I did think it all the way through, and I realized that if my suggestion was in fact true, it would imply that JW's are God's people. That's why I originally stated it, not as a straight assertion, but as a question, asking you whether the possibility had occurred to you that Jehovah was using them in such a way. I was trying to get you to reason within your own mental paradigm. I wanted you to understand that your blanket condemnation of them was inappropriate, even from your own stated point of view, with which I obviously disagree. I do not believe that JW's as an organization are or ever were God's true people.
It seems to me, though, that since Bill Bown and Mrs. Anderson have allied themselves with the faithless apostate movement that they themselves have ceased being Jehovah's Witnesses.
See, now this is the sort of remark from you that doesn't make sense. You claim that you are guided by the Bible and not the Watchtower. You claim you can defend any belief of yours using the Bible alone. You have even condemned certain actions and teachings of the Watchtower in this forum, and predicted the demise of the organization. And yet, you blindly continue to accept the organization's definition of who is an apostate, and condemn people accordingly.
To the Watchtower, anyone who was ever a JW and disagrees with their teachings or practices is an apostate. Clearly, their definition of an apostate would include you yourself, since you have openly disagreed with them several times. Bill Bowen and Barbara Anderson are no more apostate than you are. They have not denied the faith or renounced God. All they have done is point out flawed practices and corruption within the organization. For that, the organization is persecuting them. How can you condemn them for doing the same thing that you do?
It is an undeniable fact that many apostates are themselves grossly immoral.
It is an undeniable fact that many of Jehovah's Witnesses are grossly immoral, as borne out by the recent media exposures, as well as the need for constant judicial activity in nearly every congregation.
It is likewise an undeniable fact that many so-called "apostates" are fine, moral people.
For you to make a statement like this is simply an ad hominem attack on those who have seen through the organization's deceptions. It bears no weight in the mind of any thinking person, but might influence those whose thinking facilities have been weakened by the Watchtower's mind control. Which, of course, is why you constantly engage in such attacks.
no matter what the Watchtower does as far as changing its policies, or whatever, it is not going to stop sexual predators and other types of wicked absuers from doing what they do.
True enough. But if predators within the organization were regularly and systematically reported to the authorities, at least some of them would certainly be incarcerated and thus prevented from hurting any more children than they already have. Likewise, if those within the congregation were warned when there is potential danger from predators in their midst, they would be able to protect their own children from harm.