Hi Starfish and Calamityjane (Welcome!!)
My hubby was only a JW for about 12 years all together - his childhood was fairly normal for the area where he grew up - so he too doesn't totally understand my fascination with this place. He has visited a few times - just lurking - and is quite amazed by all the different people here.
I think a lot of never-been-JWs think of JWs as just being kind of a "wacky" religion - they miss the point that people who grew up in the JWs had NO CHOICE. It's almost like growing up in a family where everyone abuses alcohol - you think this is "normal" until you get out of the environment and realize that your version of "normal" is pretty horrible by other people's standards.
We also had our childhoods taken away from us and replaced with a HUGE LIE. My parents became JWs when I was maybe 7 or so... I remember how heartbroken I was when they told me that Santa Claus wasn't real... and that we wouldn't be having Christmas anymore because Jehovah didn't like Christmas and because we wanted to please Jehovah. When I learned that everything I believed in as a JW was a farce..... that there was going to be no Paradise on Earth.... no living forever... I felt the same way I did as a little girl, the day I was told that Santa wasn't real.
Now when you're a kid.... and you realize that Santa's just a fictional character.... the disappointment is normal and you get over it, move on with life and forget about it - there really is not that much harm done. But JWs put their frikkin' lives on the line for Jehovah. They are willing to go to jail for Jehovah. They are willing to die for Jehovah. They are willing to let their children die for Jehovah. They are willing to undergo public humiliation for Jehovah - going door-to-door - taking a stand on JW issues at school, at work, etc. You let opportunities pass you by, so you can focus on "keeping your eye simple" and "putting kingdom interests first" for Jehovah. You invest your entire life on that promise of living forever in paradise..... and then you find out it's all crap! That messes with your head in a big way!! Santa Claus never made all those demands of you, did he?? Seriously, finding out that the WTS is full of crap is MUCH WORSE than finding out that your parents lied to you about Santa Claus.
The fact that I was once willing to let myself or one of my children die for Jehovah makes me realize just how badly brainwashed I was. Nobody else can understand that except other people who have done exactly the same thing. The fact that there are people who understand and can empathize makes it a lot easier to cope with my own feelings of stupidity over being a JW for a quarter of a century.
Love, Scully