Yeah, at some point after you hear all these things you get curious and look something up and discover ... that the society were the ones lying and the "apostates" were the ones telling the truth.
You then look at all the other things you heard and find out that they lie about so much. It can almost be overwhelming, certainly unsettling - which is why films like "The Village" and "The Matrix" strike a chord and are often the best way to describe the experience.
For me, the science behind evolution vs creation and the flood myth, coupled with life events (having small children) made me question things and discover the emperor had no clothes.
Once you are willing to look at things honestly, you also learn that the emperor is not only naked but likes to be alone with small children and the courtiers work to cover it up.
It's a vile organization - masquerading as moral and righteous but rotten inside.