Oh and by the way, at the time, the congregation that disfellowshipped their publisher was run by the elder whose story began this post! ~ Lost
It's not unusual for someone who has hidden sins or feels guilty about their conduct to be a hard ass when judging others. All this time, they are also in fact judging themselves harshly for the indiscretion. They just cant bear to face the consequences of repenting to someone (ie, elders) and they will often excuse it because they are saving someone else (wife, family , etc) the pain of dealing with the consequences they would have.