"Splash 2" was one of the worst movies I have ever seen. I think only about 4 people ever watched that movie.
As far as Phantom Menace, I actually liked it. Sure, it wasn't a 'great' movie but I thought it was somewhat entertaining. Any time a movie is overhyped too much some people will criticize it just because it didn't meet their unattainable expectations. Matrix 2 is a perfect example. That movie kicked serious ass but some people just got their hopes up way too high I guess.