I'm really enjoying everyone's thoughts.
Since I'm not really close to people who aren't JW's (yet), I'll just give examples of what I've seen in the JW congregation...
On one hand, when my dad had a nervous breakdown a few years ago, I was amazed at the love and support we as a family received from the congregation. Public prayers were said on our behalf mentioning us by name, people brought meals over, people sent countless cards and flowers, and people spent time talking to my mother and I making sure we felt OK and finding out whether we needed someone to talk to. Some even sent us money. I truly felt Jehovah's love through them and knew they were reflecting his wonderful qualities at that time, and we received exactly what we needed.
At another time, my mom was undergoing a minor operation in the hospital. I was out in the ministry with some other pioneers, and I wanted our cargroup to drop in the hospital and go see her. One of the sisters in the group raised a fuss, stating that she didn't want to go visit her (even though she was one of her best friends) because she needed to get her time in. I was deeply upset...started crying in front of everyone...it was really embarrassing, but she only conceeded on going in to visit if her husband checked to see if there were anyone about to have a serious operation at the information desk (checking at the information desk...not operating at the information desk...LOL) he might talk to and encourage with a Bible thought. Just so she could keep her time going. I was stunned by the callousness of that.
So, I agree with others that anyone of any religion can display godlike love and compassion...just like anyone can act selfishly. In tragedy or emergency, oftentimes a person will shine with reflection of Jehovah's qualities...in other times, they may be too preoccupied with their own inner tragedies and emergencies to be of much help at all. Which just proves to me how important it is for people to take care of their own needs first.