I dated a guy for two years off and on while I was an active JW. From the time I was 16 to 18 years old. He was the sweetest guy I ever knew. He just recently married and is having his first child. My parents were never strict so it was pretty easy to get away with.
Looking back, I know they wouldn't have made such a big deal out of it. I was just keeping up appearances for the congregation members.
I dated him again for 3 months about 2 years after I became completely inactive but the feelings were not there anymore. Now they are just bittersweet memories.
Now I date "worldly" men like they are going out of style. LOL, j/k