One of the biggest complete 180 contradictions in the SAME ARTICLE, in the 9/15 study wt "Is your conscience a reliable guide?".

by EndofMysteries 11 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • EndofMysteries
    EndofMysteries

    If you actually turn your brain on and process what is being said, this article keeps contradicting itself.

    "JEHOVAH GOD created humans with free will, that is, the liberty to choose between one option and another.Neither a branch office nor the local congregation elders are authorized to make health-care decisions for a Witness. a Christian needs to remember the Biblical command “to keep abstaining from . . . blood.” (Acts 15:29) That would clearly rule out medical treatments that involve taking in whole blood or any of its four major components. Proverbs 14:15 says: “The naive person believes every word, but the shrewd one ponders each step. Reasonableness also holds us back from devoting so much time to health care that spiritual matters are forced into the background. Were we to allow health care to become the main focus of our life, we would run the risk of becoming self-centered.A Christian who is reasonable does not impose his views on others.but was it reasonable to put the unity of the congregation at risk over health care?For a time, Christians in ancient Rome had differing opinions with regard to eating certain foods and observing certain days. What advice did Paul give them? Regarding the latter, he said: “One man judges one day as above another; another judges one day the same as all others; let each one be fully convinced in his own mind.”not every pastime is beneficial, relaxing, or refreshing; nor is it good to engage in recreation too much or too often. ((Imaged of young man studying alone isolated and commenting in meetings while his friend is having a good social life and sleeping in meetings and captioned, "A bible trained conscience can help you avoid dangers"))) Do you plan recreation around theocratic activities, such as meetings, field ministry, and personal study? Or do you find yourself trying to fit theocratic activities between periods of leisure?"

    So a summary of what the article actually says. God gave everybody a conscience to help them decide what is right or wrong. Now for healthcare no branch or elders are authorized to make health choices so they can't get sued and forget what we just said about God giving you a conscience, you better not do any blood transfusions or anything with major compents of blood, if your conscience makes you think it's alright it's WRONG and we also won't take responsibility for you listening to us telling you not to take them. Proberbs says a shrewd person doesn't believe everything said but checks. Well this does NOT apply when the believing everything is in regards to what we say, what we say should be accepted without question! Back to healthcare, ignore what your conscience or body says, if your health is taking too much time then ignore it and make sure you don't miss meetings or field service, all of that is more important than being healthy! Paul told the early christians to NOT judge each other based on what they eat, or celebrate, etc. In our day that would mean we don't judge based on what people eat, or if they celebrate birthdays, christmas, etc. However that doesn't apply to us, the GB. We will judge you and tell you what you can and can't eat and celebrate BUT for the tiny slivers of freedom we allow you, don't judge each other on the decisions we allow. For example at conventions when it says 1 paper towel for drying your hands, you may decide you only need 1/2 of a paper towel, do not look down on your brother who used an entire sheet of paper towel because he was allowed 1. You conscience is also wrong on matters of recreation, ignore your God given conscience and just do what we say, mainly, meetings and field service are more important than any type of social life. If you must choose between studying and commenting at meetings but living as a hermit and social reject or social reject who can comment at meetings, then the answer is clearly stay home and study to comment at meetings! So enjoy your God given conscience and don't let anybody judge you on the decisions you make AFTER being sure to listen and follow all aspects of your life including healthcare and recreation by us!

  • EndofMysteries
    EndofMysteries
    The real funny thing though is the beginning of the article shows everyone has a conscience but they jump right into ignoring that and dictating. Then they throw a scripture about not believing everything, which is what they expect from members, but that scripture if applied would mean to ignore the crap they are saying in this article. Then they also throw in the scripture about not judging even on what people celebrate, which throws out about christmas, birthdays, etc.
  • Viviane
    Viviane
    So a summary of what the article actually says.

    By definition, a summary can't be longer than the thing it's summarizing.

  • EndofMysteries
    EndofMysteries
    By definition, a summary can't be longer than the thing it's summarizing.

    Didn't post the article, just cut and pasted a summary of the article verbatim and translated it to what it really means, hence it's still a summary of the original large article and a translation of the summary.

  • _Morpheus
    _Morpheus
    EOM, respectfully, arguing with VIV is historically a bad move. Only one person ever won an argument with viv, some legend named Morpheus. You are no Morpheus.
  • Viviane
    Viviane
    You are no Morpheus.

    You don't get to call me sugartits like FMF, so who really is the winner?

    Also, a summary can't be longer than the think it summarizes.

  • _Morpheus
    _Morpheus
    😂 darling, being your beta and calling you sugartits isnt for me, but if freemind is happy then im happy for him.
  • Giordano
    Giordano
    vas ist los......... Sugar Tits?
  • Viviane
    Viviane
    vas ist los......... Sugar Tits?

    Heck yeah, 59 double A's.

  • JeffT
    JeffT

    OK, here is a real summary:

    God gave you free will and wants you to use it to decide to do everything we tell you to do.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit