Was Being A Jehovah's Witnesses A Bad Investment For You?

by minimus 26 Replies latest jw friends

  • BLISSISIGNORANCE
    BLISSISIGNORANCE

    THE GOOD......................

    • gave up smoking
    • didn't get into relationships, breaking my pattern of bad choices in men
    • developed some self-confidence
    • had some great parties (with the spiritually weak ones of course)
    • met my gorgeous hubby

    THE BAD..........................

    • got slandered
    • got emotionally and verbally beaten up by woman-haters
    • dragged the kids to strangers doors on Saturdays yet didn't let them go to friends' houses
    • got to wear daggy clothes
    • got rid of some really cool records and cds
    • got to fight with my teenagers on just about every issue, every day
    • didn't spend much time with my childhood friends
    • stopped doing birthdays
    • had some lousy parties (with spiritually strong ones of course)

    AND THE UGLY..................

    • marked by the elders
    • child was sexually abused
    • our family was shunned
    • the pedo was playing with other kids
    • I told some mums to protect their kids
    • the elders investigated me and set up a JC
    • they got 2 false witnesses
    • I got df'ed
    • I got reinstated

    But the best investment has been leaving the borg and having a life again. My family is much happier now and we have more peace.

    Cheers, Bliss

  • maxwell
    maxwell

    Interesting question. I thought about it for a few minutes and I can't really say right now. I was raised in the religion, and it was the vehicle my parents used to teach me all sorts of positive values. It provided stability and taught me a few other skills like public speaking and selling yourself or a point. However, none of those positives are exclusive to JW and the negatives can't be denied. Of course, while growing up, I didn't put much into it myself financially. After leaving home it did take a nice chunk of my income. Of course, as a witness you believe the payoff comes in some New World. Now that I know that is all make believe, I realize all of that money is just lost. But I didn't lose enough to ruin myself and I have wasted money on other stuff as well.

  • Heatmiser
    Heatmiser

    Being an outcast all through school because your a JW. Was a straight A student all the way up to the 11th grade because at that time I finaly figured I wasn't going to college so why bother. Just a short and curly away from dropping out of school in the 12th grade. I started working when I was 15 so I could get money to get things that didn't come from a garage sale or thrift shop and save up for a used car.

    Got married before I graduated highschool (to a good JW girl that was 4 years older than me). Got divorced 4 years later because I worked to much (8 am to 4 pm and 1/2 days on every other saturday) and wasn't "theocratic" enough. Of course she wanted to stay in the borg and I didn't so I lied and told The Asses (elders) that I commited adultry so she could have "scriptural" grounds for divorce. I never did have a formal star chamber commitee meeting. A couple of elders dropped by one evening to see what was up with us splitting up. I said, "I committed adultry she is free to go." They wanted to get together and have a judicial meeting and I told them, "I am not going and I am leaving the JW's and don't come back." I am not sure when they announced my DF but nobody else came around my apartment after that night.

    Worked a bunch of dead end low paying jobs because I didn't have any education after highschool. Don't have any comunication with 1/2 my immediate family because I am DF'd.

    DEFINATLY A BAD INVESTMENT!!!!!

    It took me a few years to get my life straightened out but I am doing alright now. I have a good job and contributing to society instead of being a JW leech on society.

    Sorry about the long rant. First time in almost 12 years that I can get things out and have somebody understand what the hell I am talking about.

    Heatmiser

  • SanFranciscoJim
    SanFranciscoJim

    I can think of several reasons why being a JW was a good investment for me:

    • I was excruciatingly shy before becoming a JW. Through field service and service meetings, they taught me to be outgoing (if not downright opinionated!) Little did they know they were creating an "apostate monster"!
    • I was classified 1-A in the last year of the Vietnam draft. Being a JW got my status changed to 1-O (conscientious objector). I might not be here at all had I gone to Vietnam.
    • I learned what it was like to be a member of a high mind control cult. That experience has prevented me from ever getting caught up in that sort of thing again.
    • I learned first hand about gossip, prejudice, and intolerance, and saw how ugly it is.
  • Mysterious
    Mysterious

    I'd say it was a bad investment. Though it really wasnt my choice to invest. More like inheriting stocks in Enron..

    If I hadn't been a witness I would have made more friends. Honestly the people in the congregation are not the kind of people I get along with that well. I never went anywhere or did anything because it was "bad association".

    I missed the chance to play in an honor band, something I worked hard at to be qualified enough to receive an offer, because it was on a meeting night.

    I missed the chance to go on a band trip to a really neat place because it was four days with worldly kids.

    Despite assurances that I was not deprived of presents there were far more gift giving occasions for worldly kids. And don't say at least I didn't have to buy presents. One thing my first christmas has taught me is how fun it is to give something nice to a friend.

    I never got to sleep in. It was service this and meeting that and I never had a break to catch up on my rest. Little wonder I was always tired and adults told me I had no reason to be at my age.

    I never got involved in sports. I was a great bball player. The coach wanted me on the team but of course I couldn't. He hated me after that and I wanted to play so badly. I would have loved to play organized hockey as well or maybe bowling or another sport.

    I never got involved in leadership or student council or any of those things that look so good on scholarship applications. That cut me out of the running for SO much money.

    The jobs I applied for ALL turned me down because there were nights I couldn't work. Why hire me when there are so many kids that can work unrestricted hours.

    I was raised with such negative opinions about gays and the myth that it was a "choice" that I didn't sort out my sexuality until way after a lot of people.

    I was never in style whether it be clothes, music, hair, jewelry, or expressions. That constantly made me the "nerdy" target for everyone.

    Quite a number of movies, books, games, and bands were forbidden to me for various reasons. Some of them weren't even really good reasons, like the fact that it was fantasy or an rpg.

    At any even that served hot dogs I always lied and said I was allergic because I couldn't explain that I wasn't eating them because there might be blood in them.

    I was told not to sing songs in another language if you don't know the lyrics because it could be Pagan. This after a teacher taught us some african folk music. There was nothing wrong with those songs but the look on the teacher's face told me plainly there was something wrong with me.

    I was never in most of the concerts and plays at school because they were holiday themed. I was the only one in the band pit not playing the national anthem. I was the only fool not singing the national anthem.

    I was taught to be unfairly biased against other religions and to look down on people for their beliefs.

    And the list goes on and on. I would say it was definitely not a positive experience.

  • millie6169
    millie6169

    I think that some positive things came out of becoming a witness, but for the most part the negative things outweighed the bad, So I must say that if I could go back and change things I would never have gotten baptized because I feel that I was too young (16 years old) and I was very naive at that time. I was one of those kids that grew up with a mother that always wanted more from you...and in my quest to please my mother I submerged myself into Witness belief ...always believing that if the society said jump i'd say how high...i remember days I would be in the hall and they would announce a disfellowshipment...I would think to myself how awful and that would never happen to me..not me, I'm never going to leave "the truth"....Wow How blind I was in those days I almost wish I could go back because with everything that went down from the moment I sat in my room and doubted the society to my ultimate shunning. The reason I left was because my family and the elders always wanted more from me and they were never satisfied with my service, I was very dissappointed in the society and I questioned why they had placed a system that makes people feel like they are less than others...people were blatantly telling me that so and so person was More spiritual...and so I asked myself why am I spending every morning out in service sometimes freezing my ass off to preach the word if god would always want more. I asked myself why couldn't i go to college? why should I have to aspire to go to Bethel? to live in a place where I would further be controlled.

    SO in conclusion I think that because of the WTS I know how easily people can be controlled, I know that simple things in life are what matter and now I know I'll never take my freedoms for granted because I remember when I was living with a mom that had no problem physically abusing me because she thought she was doing the right thing by not holding back because the society told her she could.

    MOST of all I VALUE my PRIVACY. Dang...if i commit a sin I don't have to feel compelled to confess to anyone but God because I have a relationship with him and not with men. And my business is my business no more confiding in back-stabbing brothers and sisters.

    woo...that was alot of steam ...sorry

    But I feel that being a witness has set me back years...i had to leave my house and leave school to make it on my own because my mom had no problem Kicking me out of the house...Now I'm living in an apartment and I have no friends or family I feel like I have to start my life all over again, the only thing I'm glad for is that thank god i left now when I'm 21 because at least I have time to repair the damage that WTS has done to me.

  • morty
    morty

    Welcome Millie6169....

  • kitties_and_horses_oh_my!
    kitties_and_horses_oh_my!

    Welcome Millie!

    I suppose on the good side of things being a dub kept me away from underage drinking, smoking, drugs, and sex before I was ready. I learned how to speak publically and that Christmas lights still on a house in June meant the householder probably wouldn't be too mean. I'm a great fundraiser for the local Humane society because asking for money to save animals is a hell of a lot easier than forcing religion down peoples' throats.

    And as for the bad, where do I even start? I grew up with no idea of who I was or what mattered to me. I had no opinions of my own, only those of the dubs. I worked insanely hard trying to fix my broken, screwed up family. I have an eating disorder that I don't doubt has something to do with the control the religion forced on me for so long. I still have no self-esteem and blame myself for everything wrong in the world. My family doesn't talk to me, not only my parents but all my extended family I was once so grateful for. If I had it to do over, I would pray that I would never have gotten baptized...of course then I wouldn't have ended up with my fabulous husband.

    For the sake of meeting my husband it was worth it. Everything else is crap.

  • happy man
    happy man

    I am one as have been in the truth from my childhood, grown upp on it, and still inn.

    One thing who was very good was that as JW we go on diffrent assambleys, you meet a lot of peopel,where can you bee in charge over 100 persons when you are only 18, I was, inn som of this frree works on assamblies. marvelus expiriens.As a young man I also have speces to biig crowds , also an god thing fore you confidence,

    I also travel a lot to US 69, 73, meet some wonnderful peopel, never foregret the black brother as give us someplace to sleep when it shoved upp we have no place to go.

    I also meet my wife in the truth, and as a good jw SHE IS a blessing fore the man who get her, follow evry singel addvis from GB very careful, I must say, JW husbands must be some of the most happy in the word, beaucause ther wifs are traind to never go against ther husbands.

    When I grow upp I never saw this back side od this religionas we see here, fore me it was radher good, because I was not so well treated in th so called word, in fackt I was very bad treated, and harassment was a evry day fight fore mee.

    Then as young you have a feeling you was littel more important than other peopel, you was unusal, and even in schol i noticed that some was impresed that you havew the courage to bee diffrent.

    I never lived this dobbel life i read about here, but I was never pionjering , always middel man, doing my 10-15 hours, in the sevrvice you also meet o lot of diffrent peopel thisd is also one wery good thing,it is very develloping fore your personality I think to do this, I think most JW as grow upp in the religion have the same expiriens.

    But I was son off the PO so perhaps I was littel blessed from that.

    What was bad, well from the begining nothing was bad, when you was young , perhaps it was a good protection fore me to be carefull widh girls, as a long tal sweed I and my freind was radher populare among sisters when we traveld to other countries, like US, we never take addvantige of that, perhaps now I regret this a bitt, hmmmmm.

    So my life was blessed i some way, as JW, I am now well aware of the bad sides as I never saw before, now when I read here i see the backyards of our religion and it is not beautifull, so I do what I can to change it, have peopel in the cong to understand , and try to talk widh peopel even high upp as I now, about this abuse things, fore exampel, I have some sucsess in this, what I understand is that that almost evryone are aware of that here we are trapped i a difficult situaition, beaucause of GB positon and how they deal widh this .

    I dont think you peopel here are aware of the bigg impackt this hade on comen JWs, when you talk in privat about this, almost evryone say this is a dissaster fore us and must change, so we hope if not, it can be our Watrelow.

  • Guest 77

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit