Shotgun:
Stealth..did you make that comment in front of JW family members or was it privately made to the elders?
I said it to a MS that I knew would carry it to the elders and one who knew I was serious. This may not be as easy to do with a spouse living with you who is a JW.
Gary,
If I stayed silent as well as anonymous I would have missed out on knowing some of the best people I have ever known.
That is what is so great about the internet, you can remain somewhat anonymous yet, not be silenced. I have met some great people also.
I had so much contempt for the Witness people I really could not make a deal with them. Plus I didn't want to play by their rules.
This is where we differ. I don't have much contempt for the Witness people. I was one once. I think most are simply blinded by their leaders. I don't feel that I played by their rules, otherwise they would be here making shepharding calls, or looking to DF me. They are not, so they are playing by my rules IMO.
As far as Witness relatives shunning me, I wanted to know who were my friends and who valued a book publishing corporation more than me. Those who shun me because I don't read the same books as they do are out of my life and they are not welcome back.
That is easy to say, once we are on the other side. While what you say is very true, 99.9% of witnesses can't see the issue that clearly. They never see it as choosing between a book publishing company vs a family member. Did you while you were a JW? By being able to keep the lines of communication open with my own family, I have been able to help 5 out of 6 come to realize this is NOT god's organization, and yet they don't shun me.
Another dissenter was silenced. I'd say the Watch Tower won. After all, that's all they want, silence the dissenters. The shunning is just one way to keep members from listening. My audience has been the non Witnesses and former Witnesses. They can have the active ones. I don't care about them. Just my $0.02 GaryB
Yes, I have been silenced at a local level at this time. This does not mean I am completly silenced. Who knows, maybe even this post might help someone to leave on their terms.
I don't care about the active ones either, that is my whole point. They, are so concerned about loosing the active ones that they are willing to leave me alone. My priorities are... Me, my kids, my extended family, my friends..... and somewhere at the bottom of the list is active JWs.
I simply used their fear to achieve what I wanted for my family without going down a road that leaves me full of contempt for a blinded misguided people.
S