Hi Individual,
Very interesting question.
Even when you have broken free, you will still be haunted by it, watching the news just in case they were right.
I think the unsurprising answer is that it all depends on the individual.
For myself, I had held on for so many years rationalising away my doubts that when I finally did make the decisive break, there was absolutely no doubt and no going back. I never was troubled by any doubts about it.
But, interestingly, I am reminded of a conversation I had with a young woman whom I had grown up with in the same congregation. We were pretty much the same age, and this conversation took place in the early eighties when we had both been out a couple of years.
We met up for dinner, my wife and I, and she with the "wordly" (never-a-Witness)chap she had married. We laughed about the nonsense we had been taught for all those years. We got pretty drunk.
Then she said:
"But sometimes, late at night, say, when you're woken up by a fierce thunderstorm or something, don't you suddenly sit up in bed and say "Oh my God! It's Armageddon! It's happened!"
I just laughed, and told her: No. Never.
But I never forgot what she said. It said something about her.
And I was immensely saddened three or four years later (I didn't see her often, we weren't close friends) to find out that she'd gone back - and worse! She had dragged matey-boy along with her.
He is now an MS. Go figure.
Duncan.