50 years of children dying for the Watchtower.

by nicolaou 13 Replies latest watchtower medical

  • nicolaou
    nicolaou

    I'm sure there may be earlier accounts of Jehovah's Witness children dying due to the Watchtower's evil blood policy but I came across this one and had to post it. Boys and girls like Renate Gross have suffered and died for decades with no real end in sight. We may not know them but we should never forget them - I don't think any of us here do.


    ***

    w54 10/1 p. 605 Thirteen-Year-Old Berlin Girl Keeps Integrity ***

    Thirteen-Year-Old

    Berlin Girl Keeps Integrity

    THIRTEEN-YEAR-OLD Renate Grosse repeatedly complained about being very tired. The family physician, however, dismissed her complaint with the observation to her mother, "Young girls like to pretend. Don’t worry about it." But when Renate fainted at school and had to be brought home she was taken to the hospital, where her case was diagnosed as rheumatism of the joints. However, when treatment for rheumatism of the joints failed to help, a blood specialist was called in who declared her case to be leukemia, a cancer of the blood cells, for which no cure has as yet been found, and for which doctors recommend regular transfusions.

    Renate’s mother, being one of Jehovah’s witnesses, objected to blood transfusions, at which the blood specialist exploded. He simply could not understand how a mother who claimed to love her child could reject the only means of cure, and so the position of Jehovah’s witnesses on blood transfusions was explained to him in the presence of both the hospital’s head and the ward physicians. A doctor, one of Jehovah’s witnesses, made a check on the case and stated that her case had gone so far that Renate had only six weeks to live.

    Hearing of the stand taken, relatives, nurses and other ward patients bombarded both mother and Renate with arguments, but in vain. The ward physician, a Roman Catholic, insisted on overriding the mother’s objections by appealing to Renate repeatedly. One evening at 9:30 he seated himself on her bed and painted a dreadful picture of how soon she would die and in what manner, but all in vain. After he left, Renate wrote a letter expressing her convictions so that all should know that it was her decision also, not just her mother’s.

    Visited a few weeks later, she was happy, although her condition was getting visibly worse. She wanted to hear about the new things in the Watchtower and Awake! magazines, and talked little about her illness. In fact, she joked about the physician’s offer to transfuse his own blood, and she remarked: "Mom, if I should get well again, then we want to do many things differently and serve Jehovah more, but if not—then there’s this letter in my pocket, you know."

    In discussing Renate’s case with one of Jehovah’s witnesses the head physician exclaimed, "Do you believe that a girl of thirteen years can have religious convictions deep enough to refuse treatment from a physician when in danger of death?" He was assured that Renate’s own conduct answered his question, for, after learning she was to die, she was even happier and friendlier than she was before. When the matter of trying to coerce Renate was brought to his attention he was surprised to hear of it, and thereafter Renate was no longer pressured to take blood transfusions although the other ward patients showed hostility until she was taken to a private room. The head physician further observed, "In my whole practice I have never seen such a case, where a child was so happy after learning that it had to die."

    Renate died. At her funeral the letter she had written that night after the ward physician had tried to coerce her was read aloud:

    "To all relations and people I know: Dear ones, I ask you kindly but very earnestly not to make even a little bit of trouble for my mother because she refused the blood transfusion that I was supposed to get from the doctor. It is just as much my firm will to be true and obedient to God’s Word rather than to be a lawbreaker and live artificially by having a blood transfusion every half year. The words are true: ‘Whoever loves his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life in faithfulness to me will receive it again.’

    "But my big hope is not to float around in heaven somewhere as a spirit. No, but I am resting in the grave till after Armageddon, and if the great Life-giver Jehovah considers me worthy he will give me a resurrection—in honest-to-goodness flesh and blood as a human on a cleansed paradise earth in delight and happiness. So you see that is why it wasn’t hard for me to die. Can you understand that?

    "I’m young, it’s true, but I have laid my life in the Creator’s hands, and he guides everything in the right way. So in closing I ask you earnestly once again not to lay any stones in Mom’s way. Spare her all unnecessary excitement. Instead, be kind and friendly to her, and do not in any case speak evil words. Hearty greetings and kisses to you all from your loving Renate. Please take this to heart."

  • free2beme
    free2beme

    Religion kills tons of people, no faith is exempt, has been a common thread with religion since the begining. What ever beginning you choose to believe in, but mine is referencing to the beginning of any religion.

  • frankiespeakin
    frankiespeakin

    How very sad, the WT does a good job on making a person into a religious fanatic as this poor girl was. They put religion ahead of life and comonsense. Never allow a religion to lead you, think for yourself.

  • Miss_MG
    Miss_MG

    How sad and even sadder if the mother gets her brain back

  • Dragonlady76
    Dragonlady76

    This story does not make me feel sad, but rather ANGRY

    Sad is when your child dies dispite all your best efforts to save him. The featured story here was a denial of basic human rights and a crime, this girl had a chance at life, but thanks to the WT and her mother she was denied a chance at life. Life & blood are precious, how the WT cannot reconcile the two is beyond me.

    DL76

  • DelTheFunkyHomosapien
    DelTheFunkyHomosapien

    Thats so sad. Even more sad that the little was cool with it. What a waste. Can someone explain why eating steak, and anti-venom are deemed OK?

  • Aude_Sapere
    Aude_Sapere

    I can't believe that I used to find this stuff upbuilding. It's simply heartbreaking and so utterly criminal.

    As a side note:

    A letter written by the deceased.
    That's a little too personal for a witness funeral, isn't it?
    I've been to dozens of witness funerals and don't ever remember more than a a few sentences about the person being spoken.
    On re-reading, it seems that her words actually made the points of the talk.....

    -Aude.

  • nicolaou
    nicolaou
    A letter written by the deceased.

    That's a little too personal for a witness funeral, isn't it?

    I've been to dozens of witness funerals and don't ever remember more than a a few sentences about the person being spoken.

    You are right Aude, however, that funeral took place in 1954. In the past 50 years the Society have had plenty of time to standardize, homogenize, institutionalize, stereotype and systematize all cult-member funerals.

    In the eyes of the Watchtower you are not a person, not an individual - you are a publisher or pioneer or elder etc, etc.

    R.I.P. Renate Gross

  • nicolaou
    nicolaou

    Felt this was worth a little bump . . .

  • 2tone
    2tone

    sometimes I just want to burn that religion to the ground

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit