Comments You Will Not Hear at the 9-18-05 WT Study (Glory)

by blondie 15 Replies latest watchtower bible

  • Sad emo
    Sad emo

    Thanks Blondie, a great exposition as usual!

    I especially liked the use of 2 Corinthians 4:1, 2 in para. 4 with reference to 'anointed' Christians... hmmmm....

    I have a couple of questions to ask:

    1. Right at the end of para. 18 where it refers to Hebrews 6:10-12:

    but be imitators of those who through faith and patience inherit the promises.

    Is this referring to other Christians imitating the anointed Christians? If it is, isn't there a slight contradiction with para. 13:

    no one is more worthy of imitation than Jehovah God.
    2. What's the difference between being 'spirit anointed' and having 'Jehovah's powerful holy spirit upon you' (para. 12) ?
  • hamsterbait
    hamsterbait

    Blondie I really enjoyed this weeks critique.

    "WTS reality changes all the time" I am going to use that one!!

    As for Hubby saying anout the lurve - I have put my books on a seat, only to find that the person I would have been next to has mysteriously moved to another row. Since I bathe regularly and wear clean underwear dare i assume they just don't want to be near me?

    In 20 years I can count on one hand how often I have been received hospitably.

    HB

  • karly
    karly

    Blondie and others,

    I've been skimming these articles you review for some time now and enjoying your thoughts. Thank you!

    Today I had a few thoughts of my own like paragraph 13. I realized the reasoning in the paragraph was faulty.

    It states we should reflect like mirrors what God does. But God according to them, did not come to preach, he sent his son to do the work.

    Does that mean it would be okay for us to send our children out, kinda like the Mormons--actually, they follow this line of reasoning more closely.

    I don't mean this to sound like I accept the trinity teaching, I don't really.

    But I did catch faulty reasoning here. I am going to study up more on logic and argument. I think everyone would benefit on learning what a logical argument trully is. Especially if one is betting her life and happiness on a belief system.

    Does God really perservere? I mean, if you think about it, God holds the power for all things. It's more like he allows things to happen. So if we were mirroring him what would that really mean?

    I think it would mean we test our children continually, making them suffer to prove our love over and over,like some insecure, controlling, emotionally incesting parent, asking them to do something we won't even do ourselves.

    I have developed a much more balanced and personal view of God, I think now, by a lot of thought and research on my own..

    But I was just looking very hard today at the what the wt says about God and what he supposedly expects of us.

    I also noticed para 15 didn't have one scripture in it to back up the thoughts therein.

    Thank you for all your hard work. It is a reminder of how we should all be doing critical thinking about the things we read and see and hear.

  • karly
    karly

    P.S. Another thought about argumentation--

    According to the rules of logic, if a line of reasoning has just one weak part, then the whole thing is wrong--the conclusion would be wrong, even if the argument sounds totally valid. The WT does that alot. They use things we commonly accept as true, but may not be true in actual fact, to build a whole argument around, to support their theology.

    Or they have a line of logic that sounds pretty good but they omit one essential feature, like in today's lesson, and hope we aren't looking too closely at it.

  • heathen
    heathen

    Yah I'm sure the WTBTS was only reflecting Gods glory when the jumped in bed with the wild beast . Same old mumbo jumbo like just do as we tell you and you will live forever . (carrot on a stick) What I find interesting is they still claim not to have visions or come out a say they are prophets . I don't get what their deal is on this stuff they don't seem to be sure exactly what their stand is anymore .

    great job again blondie

  • xjwms
    xjwms

    A very great job Blondie

    So you gave blood, ... eh?

    I'm not there yet.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit