Euph: In Japan, karaoke is different - and much cooler - than here. Here, it's typically in a common area of a restaurant or bar, but in Japan, your party goes into its own little room with a TV and a couple couches. It's really fun, too, because you can order food and drinks to your room. They have specials during slow times of the day where you can get unlimited drinks and snacks, too. The reasoning behind banning it was that some groups of young Witnesses had gone to karaoke and things had heated up and people had gotten in trouble. I thought it was stupid because as long as you don't go as a group of horny teenagers of equal male:female ratio and get all liquored up, nothing like that is going to happen. But they saw fit to just eliminate the entire thing.
Galimo: I just wanted to comment about the human factor. Like you say, sometimes individual elders come up with silly rules that aren't specifically in any WT literature. When I was a Witness, I hated hearing about so-and-so elder doing this or that, because I felt that it was impossible for the WT Society to be responsible for the actions of every elder in every congregation.
What I realize now is that the WT Society is responsible, because it creates a culture of legalism. It is precisely because the WT Society creates such a large quantity of minute rules and asks publishers to know them and elders to enforce them, that elders and older sisters feel that they should take it on themselves to do the extra police work regarding skirt lengths and PG-13 movies. For example, imagine if, in the thousands of pages of literature it publishes each year, the WT Society emphasized using one's conscience and respecting the consciences of others. If that were made an important part of the culture, I think we would have a much lower rate of Gestapo activity and ad-hoc rules among the individuals in the congregations.
Because the Society is so directly responsible for the culture seen among Witnesses, I do hold them largely responsible for both positive and negative aspects of the human dynamics that develop within it.
SNG