Danny,
I liked your breakdown about the problems explaining the Bible's Flood. You mentioned fish, that made me think. There are thousands of different species of fresh water fish -- they would have been killed by the salt water in the oceans as they mixed together. And yet...they weren't. Not good for the bible story, huh ? Another would be insects...there are over 6,000 species of beetles, then all the flying insects like mosquitoes, bees, wasps, and others who would also have very specific dietary needs like blood, nectar from fresh flowers (Which were all killed by salt water, too).
I don't think Noah had constructed aquariums or herpitariums or insect environments to bring onto the Ark to keep them alive.
I like your ideas
1) What would I give them back?
The way I see it, you can't really take that responsibility upon your shoulders. After 35 years of being brainwashed by WT beliefs, I'm simply tickled I have the FREEDOM to look around and decide for myself what is best for me. Back when I was a regular pioneer for 3 years pre-75, I studied and 'brought in' to the WT several people. I married & then, with my JW wife, raised my kids into this shitty religion.
I am now being shunned by those same children ! I feel like I have a moral obligation to get them out of a religion I know is destructive. If I can do that, they will then have the freedom I now enjoy of deciding for myself. Right now...all religion disgusts me, I want no part of any of it. Probably it's because I feel 'stung'. That will either go away or not. Either way...I want to stop another generation from making the same mistake I did by becoming a JW. Right now I have grandkids that are being indoctrinated...
I know what you mean about the
"not being as happy now as you were as a JW," that happens for a while when such a huge belief system like this is just not there anymore -- there is a void. Especially when JW's are taught to not look too far into the real future, because the
"Paradise" is right around the corner. Our whole outlook about what our lives mean... change when we must face real life.
Rabbit