Panda,
Whoa Pole...yikes talk about twisting! You even twist your own remarks...not cunning at all. Europeans know all about America from the movies, LOL. Oh man I needed that laugh. Even Americans know movies are FICTION. And I doubt other Europeans want to put themselves into the movie culture category. But if that's how you got your education of American history I am sympathetic.
??? You break my heart! How can you be so unfair about my posts? Not again???!!!
Here is my remark again:
First of all I studied American culture and history among other things. Secondly you should know that the cultural transfer between America and Europe is one-directional. the average European knows much more about the American culture (even f it's folk knowledge from Hollywood movies), than vice versa.
There are two different points here. Plus, I've explicitly disclaimed folk knowledge.
I can't see how you were able to conclude that I got my education from Hollywood movies??? As it happens, I took 3 two-semester university courses in American Literature (starting with Winthrop, John Smith, Hawthorne, Thoreau, and Emerson and finishing in the late 1980s) and American Culture. Silly as it sounds, I even learnt big chunks of your literature and early political writing by heart.
Of course, this still doesn't prove I can't be an idiot, but it should give you an idea of what I think of your conclusion about my supposedly Hollywood-based education in AM culture.
Come on Panda, you must realize that you're being unfair...
... back to the original question.
Does Belgium have it right?
The kind of restrictions they have implemented are acceptable and apparently based on some research and monitoring. The situation there can't be compared to that in Russia, because the decisions in Russia were not preceded by any research - they were chiefly political.
The Belgian Government institutions simply know that something is wrong with the JWs. We know it too.
So I accept it as the right of the citizens of Belgium. I don't want them to accept the Polish approach to this problem. I also think Belgium is no less democratic by implementing those solutions. There is no single best democratic model in this world.