" Not really sure how that was my fault."
Our own sin is our own fault.
"If the wages of sin is death, then at my death I have paid for my sins, you can't then resurrect me and try me for the sins I just paid for and then condemn me to everlasting punishment."
Where does the bible say that physical death pays for our sins?
Physical death might pay for Adam's sin but not our own sin.
I am not and have never been a JW.
I had more to say but I just realized you are a non-believer.
Sorry.