I always gave to charity even when I was a regular,good little JW.
I remember getting "lectured" one time by a sister because I sat in a booth in a mall collecting donations for Greenpeace handing out brochures etc,, to raise public awareness.
Her words were,Jehovah is going to clean up the earth anyway so there is no need for you to be collecting money for something that is going to be fixed soon anyway and that my time would be better put to use by being in service!
It really made me angry.
I also donate to my local animal humane society,give clothes etc that I do not wear anymore to the homeless,give homeless folks downtown my change and I give to every single person who knocks on my door or accosts me in front of the liquor store on a Saturday night! LOL
Im a giver and damn proud of it!!!!
Ann