I'm not sure what to think about this. I lean toward what OldHippie said, though: Why should a homeowner get to double-dip, so to speak? It doesn't seem fair to me that a homeowner should get his house restored and then be able to keep all the money.
However, it is apparent that the Society is running a scam, and a profitable one at that. It's a real tragedy that anyone can become homeless in the blink of Mother Nature's wrathful eye. But if the Brothers have insurance, then those folks should be able to take care of themselves, and the Society should offer their help to those without the means to pay it back.
The whole point of Christianity is to "love your neighbor", meaning to be generous and compassionate to those who can't repay you. When Jesus healed (supposedly) the 12 lepers, he did it knowing that they wouldn't be able to pay him back; only one of them even bothered to say Thank You. But Jesus didn't seem upset about it.
So does the Society offer relief in places where they know that they won't be repaid? For instance, did they send relief crews to Haiti a couple of years ago in the aftermath of the terrible earthquake? Did they send people, supplies, and money knowing that the only reward would be "treasures in heaven?" Or did they figure that worldly agencies could it handle better? I'd think a little more highly of them if they sent help. My guess is they DID...............but only in the form of token help..........just for show, like the Pharisees..........in order to keep the cost down. Waaaay down. That's the way they operate.
Anyway, I still don't know what to think of a Witness homeowner getting his house fixed for free and then keeping all the money. He shouldn't allow the Brothers to even touch his house; instead, he should direct them to the house across the street where the elderly couple lost everything and have nothing and NEED the help. Now that would be Christian.
I think this stingy, profit-mongering attitude has been inadvertantly instilled in Witnesses by the Society, so maybe the little dogs learned it from the big dog, if you know what I mean.
David